FA (Referee) vs United

[ronysnaja]

dapet dari guardian nih:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2009/oct/26/alex-ferguson-referees-manchester-united

lengkapnya:


Alex Ferguson under fire from referees after new outburst at Anfield
* Louise Taylor and Andy Hunter
* guardian.co.uk, Monday 26 October 2009 22.00 GMT

Referees have responded forcefully to Sir Alex Ferguson's criticisms of their abilities by claiming the Manchester United manager's knowledge of football's rules is alarmingly hazy and that his twin attacks on Alan Wiley and Andre Marriner should prompt a stadium ban. "It's so frustrating when a manager as experienced and respected as Sir Alex Ferguson makes a statement about the laws of the game which is completely inaccurate," said Jeff Winter, a former Premier League referee.

Winter was highlighting Ferguson's insistence that Jamie Carragher should have been shown a red rather than yellow card for hauling down Michael Owen on the edge of the area during United's 2-0 defeat at Liverpool yesterday.

Another senior refereeing source, still officiating at Premier League matches, agreed with Winter. "Ferguson clearly doesn't understand the law about the denial of an obvious goal-scoring opportunity," he said. "The fouled player has to have full control of the ball and has to be moving towards the goal but Michael Owen did not fulfil either condition.

"[Sunday's match official] Andre Marriner was absolutely right to award a yellow card and a direct free-kick," he added. "It would have been totally wrong for him to have sent Jamie Carragher off. And Sir Alex should never have said that Andre Marriner was not an experienced referee when he is on the Fifa list and got all the important decisions right on Sunday."

Ferguson's latest comments, although circumspect in comparison with his criticism of Wiley, were being analysed by the Football Association's compliance department today. It is understood, however, that the FA is unlikely to bring any charges against the United manager for questioning Marriner's experience to officiate a game of Sunday's magnitude or criticising the referee's refusal to dismiss Carragher or award a penalty against the Liverpool defender for a challenge on Michael Carrick.

As a veteran of several run-ins with Ferguson, Winter wonders if United's manager was merely deflecting attention from a defeat. "I don't know if Sir Alex Ferguson has got a problem with referees but he has got a problem when Manchester United don't win and blaming the referee is the easy option," he said. "His statement about Carragher shows that either he doesn't know the laws of the game or he's resorting to mind games again."

Winter disagrees with suggestions that Ferguson is mellowing with age. "There are signs that his temper is getting worse," he said. "Some of his touchline antics, when you see the veins standing out on his neck and see him swearing and shouting, are not too good for his own health let alone anyone else's.

"I don't know whether it's age or what but he seems to be getting less tolerant of everybody and everything – especially when Manchester United don't manage to win. This sort of thing seems to be happening every other week with him now."

Like others in the refereeing fraternity, Winter is hoping that the FA will punish Ferguson severely for not just yesterday's comments but his suggestions that Wiley's fitness was suspect following United's recent 2-2 home draw against Sunderland.

"If I were the FA I would personally impose a Fifa-style stadium ban on Sir Alex," said Winter. "I think it's got to be harsh punishment to teach him and everyone else a lesson. The FA have to take serious action against him. Anything less and the Respect campaign is dead in the water. They've got to show Sir Alex and everyone else that behaviour like this will not be tolerated. A fine or, in this case, even a touchline ban won't be enough."

A stadium ban would leave Ferguson watching from the stands and barred from any contact with his players before or during a match once they have entered the stadium. In 2005 Chelsea's then-manager Jose Mourinho received a two-game stadium ban following his comments about Anders Frisk following a Champions League game against Barcelona.

Winter felt Marriner had a "very good" game but acknowledged it was the referee's first Premier League game involving two top-four teams. "There's a first time for everything, though," said Winter. "Andre did well because players from both sides had clearly been told to pressure him and I noticed that his every decision was contested by at least three players."

He also feels the FA should speed up their disciplinary procedures. "All this suggests that Sir Alex isn't really concerned about the authorities," he said. "It's three-and-a-half weeks since his comments about Alan Wiley and still nothing has happened."

Ada yang ngarti gak sih ama aturan foul di bola itu..
Menurut pandangan gw sih Carra bener2 harusnya di Red Card.. tapi kok aturannya yang disebut diatas beda ya?

mohon pencerahannya

[juliand_fergie]

dapet dari guardian nih:
.
.
.

Winter was highlighting Ferguson's insistence that Jamie Carragher should have been shown a red rather than yellow card for hauling down Michael Owen on the edge of the area during United's 2-0 defeat at Liverpool yesterday.

Another senior refereeing source, still officiating at Premier League matches, agreed with Winter. "Ferguson clearly doesn't understand the law about the denial of an obvious goal-scoring opportunity," he said. "The fouled player has to have full control of the ball and has to be moving towards the goal but Michael Owen did not fulfil either condition.
.
.
.

Ada yang ngarti gak sih ama aturan foul di bola itu..
Menurut pandangan gw sih Carra bener2 harusnya di Red Card.. tapi kok aturannya yang disebut diatas beda ya?

mohon pencerahannya

bukannya mau sok ngerti yaa, tapi kalo liat keterangan Jeff Winter diatas, yang harusnya direct red-card itu kayanya kalo si pemegang bola [Owen] ditekel pemain lawan [Carragher], saat ia sedang berlari dengan bebas kearah kiper lawan [Reina], alias posisi dia emang benar² berpotensi u/ bikin gol.. [1-on-1 dgn kiper]

sebagai contoh, mungkin ada yg inget dulu *kalo ga salah waktu lawan Newcastle* Solskjaer juga pernah di kartu merah waktu dia nekel *kalo g salah Shearer*.. posisinya waktu itu Shearer udh berlari bebas dan tinggal berhadapan dgn Schmeichel.. pemain yg paling deket cuma Ole, dan dia terpaksa menekel Shearer agar tdk terjadi gol.. alhasil, Ole pun langsung di usir wasit.

nah, sedangkan posisi Owen kemarin menurut pendapat gue emg ga seperti Shearer. posisi owen saat mendribel bola juga tidak terlalu bebas karena posisi Carra cukup berdekatan dgn Owen *alias owen tidak one-on-one dengan Reina*
mungkin itu alasannya kenapa Carra hanya di kartu kuning dan tidak langsung di usir oleh Andre Marriner...

kalo ada yg lebih mengerti lagi, mohon dikoreksi ya... :malu:

[goodfron]

Benar kasusnya owen memang blon 1 on 1 dg reina, yg perlu diertimbangkan adalah carra adl dlm posisi sbg orang terakhir di pertahanan pool ditambah owen dlm posisi sdh hampir bisa nglewatin carra andai dia gak dijatuhkan dan sdh pasti peluang utk bikin gol lbh besar dg tinggal berhadapan dg reina.
So.. Kalo saya lbh menekankan pd carra orang terakhir di lini pertahanan pool.
Begitu jg vidic seharusnya
Cukup obyektif bukan? :peace:
Posted via Mobile Device

[juliand_fergie]

Benar kasusnya owen memang blon 1 on 1 dg reina, yg perlu diertimbangkan adalah carra adl dlm posisi sbg orang terakhir di pertahanan pool ditambah owen dlm posisi sdh hampir bisa nglewatin carra andai dia gak dijatuhkan dan sdh pasti peluang utk bikin gol lbh besar dg tinggal berhadapan dg reina.
So.. Kalo saya lbh menekankan pd carra orang terakhir di lini pertahanan pool.
Begitu jg vidic seharusnya
Cukup obyektif bukan? :peace:
Posted via Mobile Device

bisa juga bro.. tapi sekali lagi, kalo baca statement Jeff Winter, Owen itu posisinya harus bener² in-charge ama tu bola.. artinya dia udh pasti berhadapan dgn Reina trus ditekel, baru mungkin bisa di red-card..

nah, pas kemaren emg menurut gw posisi Owen itu baru mau melewati Carra trus ditekel... posisinya belum bener² in-charge ama bola, makanya Andre Marriner cuman ngasih kartu kuning aja.. dan sekali lagi, perbandingan gw dengan situasi Ole waktu dulu di red card..

ilustrasi aja:

situasi Ole:
Schmeichel <======== Shearer<=== Ole


situasi Carra-Owen
Reina <======= Carra
______<====== Owen

this is just my humble opinion though... :peace:

[RedRob]

imo, pemain yang bersangkutan gak harus udah berhadapan 1 dengan 1 sama kiper... kalo gak salah banyak juga kasus seperti itu.. kalau mengacu ke pernyataan ini..

Another senior refereeing source, still officiating at Premier League matches, agreed with Winter. "Ferguson clearly doesn't understand the law about the denial of an obvious goal-scoring opportunity," he said. "The fouled player has to have full control of the ball and has to be moving towards the goal but Michael Owen did not fulfil either condition.

Owen memang gak membawa bola tersebut dalam arti men-dribble.. tapi dia melakukan sebuah flick ke arah samping dimana bola tersebut akan melewati Carra dan terkuasai untuk langsung menuju ke arah Reina.. Carra sebagai orang terakhir udah out of position untuk merebut bola, dalam arti lain, dia gak punya kontrol terhadap bola.. jadi bukan 50-50.. sehingga otomatis Owen akan punya peluang besar untuk mencetak gol.. so, kartu merah harusnya diberikan..

gw rasa, pernyataan SAF jadi berbalik menghantam dia... di kepala para wasit, disengaja atau tidak, jadi tertanam resistensi terhadap dia...

[juliand_fergie]

imo, pemain yang bersangkutan gak harus udah berhadapan 1 dengan 1 sama kiper... kalo gak salah banyak juga kasus seperti itu.. kalau mengacu ke pernyataan ini..



Owen memang gak membawa bola tersebut dalam arti men-dribble.. tapi dia melakukan sebuah flick ke arah samping dimana bola tersebut akan melewati Carra dan terkuasai untuk langsung menuju ke arah Reina.. Carra sebagai orang terakhir udah out of position untuk merebut bola, dalam arti lain, dia gak punya kontrol terhadap bola.. jadi bukan 50-50.. sehingga otomatis Owen akan punya peluang besar untuk mencetak gol.. so, kartu merah harusnya diberikan..

gw rasa, pernyataan SAF jadi berbalik menghantam dia... di kepala para wasit, disengaja atau tidak, jadi tertanam resistensi terhadap dia...

I have to agree on this one.. SAF emg sering protes keras & kena fine dari FA. kayanya wasit2 BPL bakalan kompak u/ m'jadikan SAF as their P.E. #1... :nohope:
Hopefully, they're not going to banned SAF on United's future match...
Posted via Mobile Device

[Red Army]

saya gak liat replay Owen tp info dari temen yg antek2 The Kop bilang, Carra bukan orang terakhir, krn masih ada pemain Pools lebih belakang posisinya tp tipis banget

[GL zone]

saya gak liat replay Owen tp info dari temen yg antek2 The Kop bilang, Carra bukan orang terakhir, krn masih ada pemain Pools lebih belakang posisinya tp tipis banget

pemain pool yg paling belakang posisi ny ya reina
hehehe...

ada pemain belakang pool, posisi ny kalo ga salah sejajar sama carra
tapi waktu itu jarak pemain tsb agak jauh dgn owen dan carra..

jadi, posisi carra lah yg paling deket sama owen

cmiiw

[jisung#13]

wah..ini bikin gue kesel bgt kemaren...

biarpun tipis...but in the end, carra is the last man for fool before reina..

kalo kasarnya..owen tuh lagi ngejar bola, ditarik sama last men..ya masa ndak kartu merah..

CMIIW..waktu vidic dikasi kartu kubing kedua..komentatornya bilang " terlihat sengaja" dan vidic juga ndak protes apa"..

wajarlah ngeliat fergie ngamuk" sama wasit...

[sir_otz]

United fuel rift with referees as O'Shea and Fletcher turn up heat on Atkinson
By Mark Fleming
Tuesday November 10 2009

THE hounding of referee Martin Atkinson continued yesterday as Manchester United players Darren Fletcher and John O'Shea joined the fray.

While Alex Ferguson was cleared by the English FA over his comments following United's 1-0 defeat at Chelsea and Wayne Rooney was merely warned over his future conduct after seemingly mouthing "12th man" at TV cameras, the trio could face sanctions for their criticisms.

Fletcher bizarrely blamed Arsene Wenger for the defeat, saying comments made by the Arsenal manager in September that implied the United midfielder was dirty meant he was singled out by Atkinson at Stamford Bridge.

Fletcher is unhappy at Wenger, who accused the champions of being "anti-football", and pointed the finger at "a certain player" who had gone unpunished despite making several fouls in United's 2-1 victory over Arsenal in September. It is widely accepted that Wenger was talking about Fletcher, a perception the United midfielder now believes has made him a marked man for referees.

Fletcher yesterday continued to contest Atkinson's decision to award Chelsea a free-kick for the Scot's challenge on Ashley Cole. The decision ended up being pivotal, as John Terry scored from the resulting set play.

"It was clearly not a foul. I knew at the time and I have watched it again on the replay. I back-heeled the ball and Cole just jumps up in the air and the ref gives a foul," said Fletcher.

"I think we are starting to see Wenger's comments starting to influence referees which is a shame."

O'Shea joined in the criticism of Atkinson, claiming he was influenced by the reaction of Chelsea players in giving the decisive free-kick against Fletcher. The Irish international also attacked Atkinson over his positioning for the resulting set play, describing it as "terrible".

He added: "We didn't think it was a foul in the first place. Fletch went in and came out with the ball. The ref's angle of it and the Chelsea players' reaction won them the free-kick. And then Wes was clearly fouled by Drogba as the ball came in.

"The referee's position was terrible. He was stood right behind one of the Chelsea players and was too far away to see it. Lots of decisions seemed to go against us. I crossed the ball towards the end and (Frank) Lampard clearly stuck his arm up.

"It was just outside the box, but the linesman was 10 yards away and surely had to see it. The little things just didn't go for us and we're very disappointed in that sense."

The players' attacks came as the FA indicated Ferguson will not be charged for his comments that Atkinson's position to see Drogba's clash with Brown in the decisive moment of the match was "absolutely ridiculous". It is understood the FA do not consider Ferguson's criticism of Atkinson constitutes questioning the referee's integrity.

Ferguson had: "The referee's position to make a decision was absolutely ridiculous. He can't see it. It was a bad decision but what can you do? You lose faith in refereeing sometimes. It was a bad one."

Ferguson has already admitted a charge of improper conduct for his comments on referee Alan Wiley's fitness after United's 2-2 draw with Sunderland and could face a touchline ban or fine.

- Mark Fleming


http://www.independent.ie/sport/soccer/united-fuel-rift-with-referees-as-oshea-and-fletcher-turn-up-heat-on-atkinson-1938424.html?

[ronysnaja]

Terlepas dari berbagai keputusan wasit yang lebih berat sebelah, saat ini. Yang terpenting bagi United adalah memperbaiki level permainannya. Memastikan kemenangan diraih dengan cara-cara yang mutlak sehingga tidak butuh 'keputusan' wasit. Lebih fokus dan lebih memperkaya strategi. CMIIW.

Seperti yang Flecher bilang "Now we have to raise our game and ensure these decisions are not affecting OUR game."

[derry07cantona]

jalan pintasnya skarang...
diamin aja tuh keputusan wasit...
trus perlihatkan konsistensi permainan
tampil sebagai tim juara dan bermental juara

[Ayunda]

Terlepas dari berbagai keputusan wasit yang lebih berat sebelah, saat ini. Yang terpenting bagi United adalah memperbaiki level permainannya. Memastikan kemenangan diraih dengan cara-cara yang mutlak sehingga tidak butuh 'keputusan' wasit. Lebih fokus dan lebih memperkaya strategi. CMIIW.

Seperti yang Flecher bilang "Now we have to raise our game and ensure these decisions are not affecting OUR game."


United emang harus lebih introspeksi ke dalem. Wasit mungkin emang sering merugikan United, tapi selama United bisa mencetak gol&nggak kebobolan, kemenangan pasti didapet. Moga2 kekalahan dari Chelsea jadi yang terakhir. Amin.

[hendiplast]

Sir Alex Ferguson banned for two games after Alan Wiley jibe

• Ferguson handed four-match ban, two of which suspended
• United manager to sit out Portsmouth and Everton matches


http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Football/Pix/pictures/2009/3/7/1236460336950/-Sir-Alex-Ferguson-001.jpg

The Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson has been brought to book following his criticism of the referee Alan Wiley. Photograph: Joe Toth/Joe Toth / BPI

Sir Alex Ferguson has been handed a four-match ban, two of which will be suspended and fined £20,000 for his comments made about the referee Alan Wiley last month.

The Manchester United manager has also been warned about his future conduct after he met with an FA Regulatory Commission to explain his claims that Wiley was not physically fit enough to referee, which were made following United's 2-2 draw with Sunderland.

Ferguson will now be forced to watch United's next two matches from the stands, at home to Everton and away to Portsmouth, while the suspended sanction will be automatically activated should Ferguson be found guilty of a similar charge before the end of the 2010-11 season on top of any sanction imposed for that offence.

The commission's chairman Peter Griffiths QC said after the hearing: "Each member of the commission recognised Sir Alex Ferguson's achievements and stature within the game. Having said that, it was made clear to Sir Alex that with such stature comes increased responsibilities.

"The commission considered his admitted remarks, in the context in which they were made, were not just improper but were grossly improper and wholly inappropriate. He should never have said what he did say."


http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2009/nov/12/sir-alex-ferguson-banned

[ridho_htrk]

Kamis, 12/11/2009 22:09 WIB
Fergie Dihukum Empat Laga
Kris Fathoni W - detiksport


London - Sir Alex Ferguson akan absen di bench Manchester United dalam dua partai Liga Primer ke depan. Ini adalah bagian dari sanksi untuknya usai mengkritik wasit bulan lalu.

Usai laga antara MU kontra Sunderland awal Oktober lalu, Fergie mengeluarkan komentar miring kepada wasit Alan Wiley yang memimpin pertandingan, yang dia nilai kurang fit.

Atas komentarnya tersebut, Fergie lantas didakwa atas tindakan yang tidak pantas. Sang pria asal Skotlandia itu pun sudah mengaku bersalah atas dakwaan tersebut.

Pada prosesnya, Fergie kini mendapat hukuman dari Komisi Peraturan FA berupa larangan menemani timnya di tepi lapangan dalam empat partai Liga Primer, kendati dua partai di antaranya masih ditangguhkan sampai akhir musim 2010/11.

Dua sanksi yang ditangguhkan tersebut bersifat hukuman percobaan. Artinya, hukuman akan berlaku otomatis jika Fergie ketahuan bersalah lagi atas kasus serupa sebelum akhir musim 2010/11.

Selain hukuman di empat laga tersebut, Fergie juga diharuskan membayar denda uang sebesar 20 ribu poundsterling dan mendapat peringatan atas tindakannya.

"Setiap anggota dari Komisi ini menyadari pencapaian dan eksistensi Sir Alex Ferguson dalam dunia sepakbola. Dengan begitu, jelas bahwa eksistensi Sir Alex juga harus disertai dengan tanggung jawab yang besar," ucap Ketua Komisi Peter Griffiths di situs MU.

"Komisi ini sudah mempertimbangkan pengakuannya atas pernyataan tersebut, dalam konteks pernyataan yang sudah dilontarkan itu bukan hanya tak pantas tapi sangat tidak layak. Dia seharusnya tidak mengeluarkan komentar itu," lanjut Griffiths.

Dengan hukuman ini, artinya Fergie harus menyaksikan pertandingan dari kursi penonton ketika MU menjamu Everton dan kemudian melawat ke markas Portsmouth.

( krs / key )

wahhh...tanpa opa ni di bench... mudah2 an pemain United tahu apa yg diinginkan opa...

[cr7lover]

moga2 permaenan United ga jadi kacau karena ini :(

[rondwisan]

we'll never die - we'll never die ....
c'mon United ...., buktikan bahwa tanpa Opa di pinggir lapangan pun, KAMU BISA .... !!!!

[pweechevalier]

moga2 permaenan United ga jadi kacau karena ini :(

we'll never die - we'll never die ....
c'mon United ...., buktikan bahwa tanpa Opa di pinggir lapangan pun, KAMU BISA .... !!!!

Yup!!! Moga2 meski tanpa didampingi SAF di pinggir lapangan, United tetap dapet hasil maksimal...
Seperti lagunya U2...
" With or without you...with or without you...
I can win...with or without you..." :putra:

wisnu cimol

[hendiplast]

Fergie Dihukum Empat Pertandingan dan Denda Rp 311 Juta

http://www.kompas.com/data/photo/2009/11/04/0734051p.jpg

LONDON, Kompas.com - Federasi Sepak Bola Inggris (FA) menjatukan hukuman kepada Sir Alex Ferguson tak boleh mendampingi Manchester United dalam empat pertandingan Premier League. Selain itu, sang pelatih juga dikenakan denda sebesar 20.000 poundsterling atau sekitar Rp 311 juta.

Hukuman ini terkait dengan pernyataan Fergie yang mengkritik kinerja wasit Alan Wiley, saat memimpin duel MU versus Sunderland (3/10). Saat itu, Fergie mengatakan bahwa kondisi Wiley kurang bugar sehingga tidak bisa memimpin pertandingan dengan baik. Meskipun demikian, Fergie dengan sigap menyampaikan permintaan maaf kepada Wiley beberapa hari kemudian.

Namun, pernyataan maaf tersebut tidak digubris FA. Pasalnya, FA memutuskan untuk menghukum Fergie untuk tidak boleh mendampingi timnya selama empat pertandingan. Rencananya, dua hukuman akan berlaku dalam waktu dekat. Sedangkan, sisanya belum diputuskan kapan akan berlaku. Selain itu, Fergie harus membayar denda sebesar Rp 311 juta.

"Setiap anggota dari komisi ini menyadari pencapaian dan eksistensi Sir Alex Ferguson dalam dunia sepak bola. Dengan begitu, jelas bahwa eksistensi Sir Alex juga harus disertai dengan tanggung jawab yang besar," jelas Ketua Komisi Peter Griffiths

"Komisi ini sudah mempertimbangkan pengakuannya atas pernyataan tersebut, dalam konteks pernyataan yang sudah dilontarkan itu bukan hanya tak pantas tapi sangat tidak layak. Dia seharusnya tidak mengeluarkan komentar itu," imbuhnya.

Ini bukan pertama kalinya Fergie terkena hukuman karena mengritik wasit. Pada tahun 2003 dan 2007, pelatih berusia 67 tahun itu juga pernah terkena hukuman dua pertandingan tak boleh mendampingi timnya. (TLG)

[marsel david]

semoga pemain2 United bisa main dengan maksimal walaupun tanpa di dampingin SAF ..
amiin..

[zudomiriku]

'Hukuman untuk Sir Alex Terlalu Ringan'
Narayana Mahendra Prastya - detiksport



London - Hukuman yang diberikan oleh FA kepada manajer Manchester United Sir Alex Ferguson dinilai mengecewakan oleh serikat wasit. Sanksi tersebut dinilai terlalu ringan.

Ferguson dihukum empat laga usai mengeluarkan komentar pedas terhadap wasit Alan Willey yang memimpin pertandingan MU vs Sunderland.

Dengan sanksi tersebut maka Setan Merah tidak akan didampingi Ferguson ketika menghadapi Everton dan Portsmouth. Sementara dua partai lainnya masih ditangguhkan sampai akhir musim 2010/11.

Dua sanksi yang ditangguhkan tersebut bersifat hukuman percobaan. Artinya, hukuman akan berlaku otomatis jika Fergie ketahuan bersalah lagi atas kasus serupa sebelum akhir musim 2010/11.

Hukuman ini dinilai oleh serikat wasit Prospect terlalu ringan. "Dari pandangan kami keputusan FA mengecewakan. FA punya kesempatan untuk menciptakan sesuatu yang menjadi titik tolak dan mereka tidak menggunakannya," demikian diungkapkan Alan Leighton dari Prospect, diberitakan AFP.

Prospect menilai hukuman ini tidak memberikan efek yang tepat untuk manajer-manajer yang lain.

"Penilaian kami bukan didasari dendam pribadi terhadap Sir Alex. Namun Sir Alex memiliki kedudukan khusus dalam kompetisi ini."

"Bila hukuman yang dijatuhkan tampak terlalu ringan, maka manajer lain akan berpikir bahwa apa yang dia katakan itu tidak di luar batas," tuntas Leighton.

[drivemein]

Fergie 'happy' with two-match ban
-Independent.ie-

ALEX FERGUSON is set to forego an appeal against a two-match touchline ban and £20,000 fine after the English Football Association was accused of 'flunking' the Manchester United manager's punishment for questioning the fitness of referee Alan Wiley.

Ferguson was handed a two-match touchline ban -- with two further games suspended until the end of the 2010-11 season -- plus a fine following a two-and-a-half-hour personal hearing in front of an FA regulatory commission in London yesterday.

But that punishment has been described as too lenient by Alan Leighton, national secretary of Prospect, the union which represents referees, and of failing to support the FA's 'Respect' campaign.

Leighton, a vociferous critic of Ferguson since the Wiley controversy erupted, had called for the United manager to be hit with a Uefa-style touchline ban, which would have also prevented him from accessing the team dressing-room on matchdays.

Leighton said: "From our point of view it is disappointing. The Football Association had a chance to make a point and they flunked it. To question the fitness of a referee is to question his ability to do the job and his integrity. We don't think this is sending the right message out to other managers."

Sources close to the United manager have described the Scot as "quite happy" with the outcome, despite the FA breaking with precedent by issuing a touchline ban for post-match comments.

But while Ferguson has until 6pm today to appeal against the punishment, it is understood that he will accept the sanction and serve his ban during the Premier League games against Everton at Old Trafford on November 21 and the fixture against Portsmouth at Fratton Park the following week.

[drivemein]

Wiley could sue Fergie for defamation
-soccernet.espn.go.com-

http://soccernet-assets.espn.go.com/design05/images/2009/1012/siralexferguson20091012close_275x155.jpg

Alan Wiley could yet sue Sir Alex Ferguson for defamation after the referee union revealed it would discuss possible legal action against the Manchester United manager following comments that earned him a two-match touchline ban.

FA bans Fergie for two games

The FA this week handed Ferguson his ban, plus two further matches suspended and a £20,000 fine for saying Wiley "just wasn't fit enough" to take charge of United's 2-2 draw with Sunderland last month.

Alan Leighton, national secretary for referees' union Prospect, said: "One of the things we are saying is, is there a case these comments are defamatory? I intend to talk to Alan Wiley to see if he wants to sue on the issue.

"We need to take a few steps back and see what has happened here and I would like to see more about the judgement. We never wanted to get lawyers involved in but if referees don't feel they are being protected by the regulatory bodies and someone says something defamatory sooner or later someone is going to take action over it.

"We are going to talk to the relevant authorities to see what it means for the future. I'll also talk to our members. I think there will be a concern this isn't an appropriate way to send a message that these comments were wholly unacceptable.''

Ferguson's ban means he will miss matches at home to Everton and away at Portsmouth.

[fredrian.seven]

Mo nanya...hukuman dilarang mendampingi tim dari pinggir lapangan apa termasuk nggak boleh memberi intruksi di ruang ganti ya?

[Oncy]

Ngga bro, setau gw hanya tdk boleh duduk di bench aja... Ttp bs memberikan isntruksi kpd asistennya dan saat halftime... Kecuali di banned nya tdk boleh hadir di stadion...

[fredrian.seven]

Ngga bro, setau gw hanya tdk boleh duduk di bench aja... Ttp bs memberikan isntruksi kpd asistennya dan saat halftime... Kecuali di banned nya tdk boleh hadir di stadion...

Klo gitu Fergie masih bisa pake jurus hairdryer-nya klo permaenan MU nggak memuaskan pas jeda babak II.

[Red Army]

sempat gak percaya kalo Gergie bakalan di banned
ban di mulai away ke Everton minggu depan & menjamu Portsmouth seminggu kemudian

[sir_otz]

Evans in referees blast
Defender unhappy with officials
Last updated: 13th November 2009

Jonny Evans believes Manchester United have been getting a raw deal off referees this season.

The Northern Ireland international feels the reigning Premier League champions have not been getting the benefit of some 50-50 decisions in recent games.

United boss Sir Alex Ferguson and a number of players were unhappy with a host of decisions given by referee Martin Atkinson during last weekend's defeat at Chelsea.

United were aggrieved Atkinson awarded a foul against Darren Fletcher for a challenge on Ashley Cole in the build-up to Chelsea's winning goal, while they felt Didier Drogbapulled Wes Brown's shirt as John Terryscored the winner.

Evans believes United are having to beat the officials on some occasions to get results.

"We are usually quite good with referees," Evans told Sky Sports News. "I think there are a lot of teams that do a lot of playacting, but I don't think that's the case with Manchester United.
"I think we do try and play fair and not many of us would roll around and try and cheat.

"Sometimes the 50-50 decisions, that you would hope because of that would go in your way, have not been really going our way lately and I think that's what has maybe been disheartening a few of the lads, but that's football.

"Sometimes you have got to beat the referee as well and that is what we are going to try and do."


http://www.skysports.com/story/0,19528,11667_5693379,00.html?

[otonk reddevilz]

Jum'at, 20 November 2009, 06:50 WIB
Preview MU vs Everton
Hukuman Ditangguhkan, Ferguson Dampingi MU

VIVAnews - Kabar gembira buat Manchester United. Hukuman empat laga yang diterima Sir Alex Ferguson belum diberlakukan saat MU menjamu Everton, Sabtu 21 November 2009 nanti.

Ferguson akan tetap memimpin Iblis Merah saat meladeni tim besutan David Moyes di Old Trafford. Seperti yang dilansir Goal, hukuman Ferguson akan ditangguhkan hingga 14 hari sejak hukuman itu dijatuhkan.

Sebelumnya, Ferguson memang telah dijatuhi hukuman larangan mendampingi timnya dalam dua pertandingan tahun ini dan dua lainya di musim kompetisi 2010-2011.

Kehadiran Ferguson ini tentu akan melecut semangat Wayne Rooney cs. Terlebih kekuatan MU juga mendekati sempurna. Hanya John O'Shea yang kabarnya cedera usai membela Irlandia di pertandingan playoff Kualifikasi Piala Dunia.

Di barisan depan, Fergie akan kembali menduetkan Dimitar Berbatov dengan Wayne Rooney. Striker Bulgaria ini mulai pulih dari cedera. Michael Owen juga bisa menjadi solusi jika Berbatov masih belum maksimal.

Sedangkan di barisan pertahanan, Jonny Evans rupanya akan diduetkan dengan Nemanja Vidic setelah Rio Ferdinand masih diragukan. Keduanya akan diapit Patrice Evra dan Wes Brown sebagai bek sayap.

Di barisan tengah Ferguson tentu lebih memiliki banyak pilihan. Ryan Giggs, Nani, Anderson, Gabriel Obertan, Michael Carrick, Darren Fletcher, Paul Scholes dan Antonio Valencia siap diturunkan.

Sejarah pertemuan juga masih berpihak pada tuan rumah. Sejak format berubah menjadi Premier League, MU hanya sekali mengalami kekalahan dari The Toffees di Old Trafford.
• VIVAnews

sumber : http://bola.vivanews.com/news/read/107332-hukuman_ditangguhkan__ferguson_dampingi_mu

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

nih komisi wasitnya khilaf kayaknya yah...hehehe...baguslah...

[Red Army]

untung United menang terus saat Fergie gak mendampingi di pinggir lapangan, besok2 sabar ya opa, selain gak bagus buat klub juga gak bagus tuk kesehatan kalo sering marah2...

[Ayunda]

Ngga bro, setau gw hanya tdk boleh duduk di bench aja... Ttp bs memberikan isntruksi kpd asistennya dan saat halftime... Kecuali di banned nya tdk boleh hadir di stadion...


Pengetahuan baru, nih. Mo tanya juga, bro. Sanksi nggak boleh hadir di stadion tu kalo kesalahan pelatih udah seberapa parah tingkatnya? Makasih. Maaf oot. :P

[sir_otz]

Standard Ganda lagi dari FA ??? :sikat::sikat::hajar3::hajar3:
JBYpzicKdsU

[B4YU]

versi gif nya yah

http://i42.tinypic.com/2r20kch.gif

http://i43.tinypic.com/34hbd77.gif

setelah Masch yg demikian jelas bebas ... masak bisa kembali terulang....[-X

[rondwisan]

ach lebay nih Caldwell ..., emang supporter Wigan akan diem aja yaa klo ada pemainnya dilanggar lawan ... :sikat::sikat:
__________________________________

Caldwell: Supporters influenced ref
Soccernet - November 22, 2010


Wigan defender Steven Caldwell felt referee Martin Atkinson's crucial decisions were influenced by the huge Old Trafford crowd in Saturday's 2-0 defeat to Manchester United.

Captain Antolin Alcaraz was dismissed for a second bookable offence after half-time, while striker Hugo Rodallega also saw red two minutes later and Charles N'Zogbia was denied what the Latics felt was a clear penalty with the score still goalless.

"I wasn't even worried he [Alcaraz] might go off for the [second] challenge, to be honest,'' Caldwell told the Wigan Evening Post. "There were tackles flying in from their side - and I know I'm biased - that weren't getting punished, and could possibly have been bookings.

"But I thought it was an honest challenge from Antolin to get the ball, and although it was a certain foul on Fletch, which we accept, I just felt the referee could have shown a bit of leniency. Maybe the pressure from the crowd and whatever meant he sent him off.

"I also thought it was a stonewall penalty and I'm certain that if it had been a Manchester United player it would have been a penalty. I said that to the referee at half-time, and he said he felt that Charlie went down far too easily.

"My argument was why would he go down when he was in such a strong position. It was such a big decision that had a bearing on the game, because they got their first goal within a couple of minutes and all of a sudden we're 1-0 down at half-time.''

Caldwell's claim is far from the first time an opposition player or manager has accused officials of giving decisions in favour of United.

In January 2005, Roy Carroll clearly fumbled a long-distance effort from Tottenham's Pedro Mendes into the net, but the goal was not given, while in 2009, then West Brom boss Tony Mowbray accused referee Rob Styles of "being in awe" of United's players after he controversially sent off Baggies defender Paul Robinson.

And this season, Mark Clattenburg courted controversy after allowing Nani's goal against Spurs to stand amid confusion about whether a free-kick had been awarded against the Portuguese winger. That incident came a week after Stoke manager Tony Pulis accused officials of double standards following Andre Marriner's failure to to show Gary Neville a second yellow card for a poor challenge on Matthew Etherington.

[rondwisan]

Ferguson faces ban over ref blast
ESPNsoccernet - March 3, 2011


Sir Alex Ferguson could be forced to watch from the stands as Manchester United pursue the Premier League title as the FA considers punishing the manager for his criticism of referee Martin Atkinson.

Ferguson was scathing in his appraisal of Atkinson's performance in United's 2-1 loss to Chelsea on Tuesday and he also said he "feared the worst" when the official was appointed to the match and implied Atkinson is not a "strong" or "fair" referee.

Managers disagreeing with controversial decisions is tolerated to some extent but the fact Ferguson questioned Atkinson's ability to handle the match could see him handed a two-match ban. Ferguson already has a suspended two-match sentence hanging over his head from his 2009 comments claiming Alan Wiley was not fit enough to referee, meaning he could face four or more matches away from the sideline if he is found guilty for this latest indescretion.

The FA has asked to see footage of Ferguson's post-match interviews to determine exactly what the manager said and in what context. It is understood Ferguson, even if found guilty, should be free to take his place in the dugout at Anfield on Sunday as United try to bounce back from the Chelsea defeat at Liverpool. Any ban would come into effect after that although an appeal by United would likely play out next week. The first match Ferguson might miss is the FA Cup quarter-final against title rivals Arsenal.

Ferguson said after the Stamford Bridge match: "You hope you get a strong referee in games like this. It was a major game for both clubs. You want a fair referee - or a strong referee, anyway - and we didn't get that. I don't know why he has got the game. I must say, when I saw who the referee was I did fear it. I feared the worst."

Ferguson argued that Atkinson should have given Chelsea defender David Luiz a second yellow card for off-the-ball fouls on Wayne Rooney and Javier Hernandez and that the penalty awarded when United defender Chris Smalling impeded Yuri Zhirkov should not have been given.

But it is the use of the word "fair" and Ferguson's implication that he had pre-judged Atkinson's ability before the match had taken place that have put the Scot in hot water.

[bang_zak]

ah lebay amath si FA nya yack...nyata nyata kejadian dilapngan emang demikian...wasitnya tu yang diurusin biar ga sekelas ISL...:hammer:

[finza_13]

opa SAF emang terkenal keras klo masalah beginian,jd ya ga heran jg sih udah beberapa kali,demi United apapun dilakukan,apalagi point krusial seperti lawan Blues :amazed:

[ario adi nugroho]

Ferguson "Bernyanyi", FA Menghukum

Sir Alex Ferguson dinyatakan bersalah oleh FA akibat mengecam wasit Martin Atkinson.

FA menjatuhkan sanksi tegas kepada Sir Alex Ferguson menyusul reaksi yang dimunculkan manajer Manchester United itu ketika dikalahkan Chelsea 2-1, Selasa (1/3) lalu.

Ferguson mengecam keputusan wasit Martin Atkinson karena memberikan hadiah penalti yang berujung gol kemenangan lawan. Ferguson murka karena Atkinson tidak mengusir David Luiz yang menjatuhkan Javier Hernandez dan Wayne Rooney meski sudah mengantungi kartu kuning.

"Kita inginkan wasit yang adil atau wasit yang tegas dan kami tidak mendapatkannya. Harus dibilang, ketika saya melihat siapa wasitnya saya sudah takut. Ternyata ketakutan saya terbukti," ujarnya kepada MUTV.

FA menyatakan Ferguson bersalah dan siap menjatuhkan sanksi, tetapi sang manajer diberi kesempatan menyampaikan tanggapan hingga Selasa mendatang.

Jika sanksi diberlakukan, Ferguson akan absen ketika United menghadapi Arsenal pada putaran keenam Piala FA di Old Trafford, 12 Maret mendatang, ditambah pertandingan Liga Primer Inggris melawan Bolton Wanderers sepekan setelahnya.

http://www.goal.com/id-ID/news/1108/sepakbola-inggris/2011/03/04/2377974/ferguson-bernyanyi-fa-menghukum

[zudomiriku]

Ferguson charged over Atkinson comments

http://i682.photobucket.com/albums/vv189/zudomiriku/zudo%20II/saf.jpg


Sir Alex Ferguson has been charged with improper conduct by the Football Association.

Ferguson has until 4pm on Tuesday, March 8 to respond to the charge, which relates to comments made about referee Martin Atkinson immediately after Manchester United's Premier League defeat at Chelsea.

Five great manager vs referee bust-ups starring Fergie, Wenger, Jose, Big Sam and Paul Jewell

The United boss was fuming at Atkinson over his failure to dismiss Chelsea goalscorer David Luiz for clear fouls on Javier Hernandez and Wayne Rooney after the Brazilian had already been booked.


To compound that frustration Atkinson then awarded Chelsea what he considered a "soft" penalty when Yuri Zhirkov fell under Chris Smalling's challenge.

Although Ferguson's comments to host broadcaster Sky Sports are not thought to have overstepped the mark, those to United's in-house TV station MUTV have caused concern.

"You want a fair referee, or a strong referee anyway - and we didn't get that," said Ferguson in the aftermath of the 2-1 defeat.

"I must say, when I saw who the referee was I feared it. I feared the worst."

The Football Association asked MUTV for footage of the interview to check the context in which Ferguson delivered the words.

And, even though he immediately softened his stance, altering the word 'fair' to 'strong', disciplinary chiefs feel there is sufficient malice to warrant charging him in a week when Wayne Rooney escaped further punishment for elbowing James McCarthy at Wigan last week.

Even Ferguson accepted his star striker had been "fortunate".

The Scot, who has decided not to hold a press conference ahead of Sunday's FA Cup tie with Liverpool, has not been so lucky and unless he can persuade the FA of his innocence, is facing a lengthy period away from the dug-out.

Ferguson already has two matches of a four-game ban still hanging over him following his ill-advised comments about Alan Wiley last season, when he implied the official was not fit enough for his job.

Those games will be triggered if guilt is established, which would condemn him to the stands for United's FA Cup sixth-round tie with Arsenal at Old Trafford on March 12, plus the Premier League encounter with Bolton seven days' later.

Punishment for his latest indiscretion would be added.

http://bleacherreport.com/tb/b8k5g

[ario adi nugroho]

Ferguson Akan Ajukan Banding

Ferguson Akan Ajukan Banding


Manajer Manchester United Sir Alex Ferguson sepertinya telah memutuskan untuk melawan ancaman larangan duduk di bangku cadangan akibat mengritik kepemimpinan wasit Martin Atkinson setelah kalah 2-1 dari Chelsea.

Jurubicara Setan Merah menyatakan, "Sir Alex telah menyatakan kepada FA hari ini tentang bantahan terhadap tuntutan itu. Ia juga meminta dengar pendapat pribadi."

Ferguson terancam hukuman panjang jika tetap dinyatakan bersalah dalam mengritik wasit secara berlebihan.

Atkinson dianggap merugikan United, terutama karena tak mengganjar bek Chelsea David Luiz dengan kartu kuning kedua saat melanggar Wayne Rooney.

http://www.goal.com/id-ID/news/1108/sepakbola-inggris/2011/03/05/2379470/ferguson-akan-ajukan-banding

[VaDLi]

The Football Association today announced that Sir Alex Ferguson has been handed a five-match touchline ban and £30,000 fine after being found guilty of an improper conduct charge.
The ban is due to start on Tuesday 22 March. So Sir Alex should be in the dug-out against Bolton !!
WTF !!

http://www.manutd.com/en/News-And-Features/Football-News/2011/Mar/Boss-banned-for-five-games.aspx

(against westham, fulham, city,
everton & arsenal) :nohope:

______

MUFC's record in games
during SAF touchline bans: P8 W6 D0
L2, losing v Fulham (1-3 in 2003)
and at West Ham (1-2 in 2007)

[VaDLi]

5 match setelah bolton, opa SAF ga bisa nemenin di pinggir lapangan

Sat 19/03/11 PRL Manchester United
22 : 00
Bolton Wanderers

Sat 02/04/11 PRL West Ham United
18 : 45
Manchester United

Sat 09/04/11 PRL Manchester United
21 : 00
Fulham

Sat 16/04/11 PRL Newcastle United
PTSP
Manchester United

16/04/11 FAC Manchester City
21 : 00
Manchester United

Sat 23/04/11 PRL Manchester United
18 : 45
Everton

Sun 01/05/11 PRL Arsenal
20 : 05
Manchester United


Sat 07/05/11 PRL Manchester United
21 : 00
Chelsea

Sat 14/05/11 PRL Blackburn Rovers
21 : 00
Manchester United

Sun 22/05/11 PRL Manchester United
22 : 00
Blackpool
http://img.kaskus.us/images/kaskusmobile_hp.gif

[Oom Panda]

Well... Juara tahun ini akan jauh lebih manis...
Bring it!!!
Don't care much... Ntar SAF pake bbm instruksiin ke Mike Phelan...
http://img.kaskus.us/images/kaskusmobile_hp.gif

[fredrian.seven]

Akhirnya.. 5 pertandingan. Termasuk lawan arsenal juga. Moga United nggak terlalu kepengaruh. 5 pertandingan termasuk di dalamnya lawan citi dan arsenal.. Wih. Duet phelan dan muelensten bakal kerja keras nih.
http://img.kaskus.us/images/kaskusmobile_hp.gif

[bucay deathbat]

Dapet info dari FB :

Pertandingan vs Bolton besok akan tetap didampingi oleh SAF, karena hukuman SAF berlaku mulai tanggal 22 Maret. Pertandingan yg akan dilewati SAF adalah vs Westham (A), Fulham (H), City (N-FA cup), Everton (H), & Arsenal/Newcastle (A). Dengan ini maka assisten manajer, Mike Phelan yg menjadi pengganti SAF.

bener gk ya ?
:)
tolong dibantu yak . .
:beer:

[finza_13]

Opa harus merelakan big match di luar lapangan nih..
smoga tetep bs teriak2 deh :siul:

ini kan jg bukan pertama kalinya,mungkin tdk akan terlalu berpengaruh besar buat permainan tim :devil1:

[rondwisan]

hmmm ... 5 match yaa ..., is it a kind of new record ... :hammer::hammer::hammer:
cuti sekalian aja deh Opa ... :(

[rondwisan]

Fergie sanction too harsh - Ancelotti
ESPNsoccernet - March 17, 2011


Chelsea manager Carlo Ancelotti believes the five-match touchline ban handed to Sir Alex Ferguson by the Football Association is too strong.

The Manchester United manager was given the ban and a £30,000 fine for his verbal attack on referee Martin Atkinson at Chelsea last month. However, Ancelotti believes the punishment does not fit the crime and questioned what the governing body is hoping to achieve with the ban.

''I think that, my opinion, is that Ferguson has always had good behaviour and I think five games now is too much,'' he said. ''There is no reason he has to be out for five matches and I do not think that can change their strength and the power of Manchester United.''

He added: ''I know what he said after the game. Obviously it was not good behaviour but five games is too much.''

Ferguson criticised Atkinson's failure to send Blues defender David Luiz off for fouls on Javier Hernandez and Wayne Rooney after the Brazilian had already been booked, then expressed comments the FA disciplinary panel felt had questioned the official's integrity.

''You want a fair referee, or a strong referee anyway - and we didn't get that,'' said Ferguson in the aftermath of the 2-1 defeat. I must say, when I saw who the referee was I feared it. I feared the worst.''

[Dika Ncit's]

wew 5 match.. lumayan jg tuh..

dendanya jg lumayan :D

for :mudance: trussss bejuang...!!!

[bang_zak]

Hahaha...gw heran ya,nyata nyata itu kejadian bener adanya,wajarlah orang protes apalagi ini berkaitan dengan titel juara...protesnya terlalu keras?well...sebaiknya FA harus nonton ulang itu pertandingan berkali kali...

[ferly_Liemz]

Seharusnya di bablas ae sekalian ampe akhir musim,biar SAF cuti sekalian...

Pantas di hukum iya, tapi lebay atau gak? Ya lebay lah...

Tp SAF termasuk Bad sih di mata FA
http://img.kaskus.us/images/kaskusmobile_hp.gif

[x_ray]

terlalu berat tuch hukumannya..
masa sampai 5 pertandingan..
1 pertandingan aja cukup :P

emang kenyataannya wasitnya yg oon gitu :hajar2:

[derry07cantona]

FA ketakutan ama omongan media
kampret tuh FA...

[zudomiriku]

Ancelotti: Hukuman untuk Sir Alex Terlalu Berat
Narayana Mahendra Prastya - detiksport



London - Manajer Chelsea Carlo Ancelotti bersimpati kepada arsitek Manchester United Sir Alex Ferguson yang dikenai sanksi dilarang mendampingi tim dalam lima laga. Ancelotti menilai hukuman itu terlalu berat.

Sanksi sebanyak lima pertandingan itu dijatuhkan oleh FA menyusul kritik Ferguson terhadap wasit Martin Atkinson yang memimpin laga antara Chelsea kontra MU. Sir Alex mengecam Atkinson karena tak memberikan hukuman tegas kepada David Luiz yang melanggar Javier Hernandez dan Wayne Rooney.

Selain larangan mendampingi tim, manajer asal Skotlandia itu juga harus membayar penalti sebesar 30 ribu poundsterling.

Ancelotti berpendapat bahwa hukuman yang harus diterima Ferguson terlalu berat. "Menurut pendapat saya, Ferguson selalu bersikap dengan baik dan saya pikir hukuman lima pertandingan itu terlalu berat. Tidak ada alasan bahwa dia harus absen dalam lima pertandingan," kata manajer asal Italia itu di Soccernet.

"Saya tahu apa yang dikatakan Ferguson setelah pertandingan melawan Chelsea. Jelas itu bukanlah tindakan yang bagus. Namun sanksi lima pertandingan tetap terlalu banyak," tandas manajer yang akrab disapa Don Carletto itu.

Ancelotti menilai bahwa absennya Ferguson dari pinggir lapangan juga tidak akan memberi pengaruh signifikan bagi The Red Devils. "Saya pikir kondisi itu tidak menimbulkan perubahan terhadap kekuatan Manchester United," tutup mantan pelatih Parma, Juventus, dan AC Milan itu.

[Panji]

klo buat gua...carra emg sdh ckup krtu kuning, karena carra bukan org trakir, tp posisinya sejajar dgn owen...hanya saja hukuman FA buat SAF tlalu berat...5 pertandingan menurut gw jelas bs mempengaruhi kndisi team di lapangan...

[red_devilz]

Bisa mengajukan banding gak sih ? Or udah final tuh hukuman ? Kalau bisa banding , trus dikurangi mjd 2-3 laga kan lumayan :shakehand: .

[Redsbusby]

Fergie uda terkenal sbg 'badboy' sih di jajaran pengurus FA terutama korps pengadil lapangan, jadi ya FA gak pernah nanggung2 kalo ngasi hukuman... Tp 5 matches untuk laga yg jelas2 verat sebelah?? Come onnn......:-q

[Hand_rooney]

Fergie uda terkenal sbg 'badboy' sih di jajaran pengurus FA terutama korps pengadil lapangan, jadi ya FA gak pernah nanggung2 kalo ngasi hukuman... Tp 5 matches untuk laga yg jelas2 verat sebelah?? Come onnn......:-q

andai antek2 NH ada di FA, bisa dikurangin tuh hukuman, tergantung "upeti"...[-O<

ada yg punya statistik hasil United saat ga didampingi SAF ga?

[MUFC1878]

dont care !!! mo banned 38 laga juga kalo JUARA ya JUARA:devil2:


cm emang FA dah bosen kali liat united juara molo...ada aja cara2 "terselubung" buat mempengaruhi jalan menuju juara :hajar2:

[Redsbusby]

ada yg punya statistik hasil United saat ga didampingi SAF ga?

Wah saya lupa..
seinget saya 2 musim lalu pernah deh, hasilnya seri, lupa...
Mungkin bisa colek red_devilz aja om. biasanya doi hafal klo hal2 beginian :shakehand:


cm emang FA dah bosen kali liat united juara molo...ada aja cara2 "terselubung" buat mempengaruhi jalan menuju juara :hajar2:

Bisa jadi bro,
soalnya prsiden FA, bernstein kan mantan pejabat citizen :amazed:

[zudomiriku]

Bisa mengajukan banding gak sih ? Or udah final tuh hukuman ? Kalau bisa banding , trus dikurangi mjd 2-3 laga kan lumayan :shakehand: .

mending terima aja seh, ntar kalo banding hukuman ditambah bisa berabe lagi. dlm 'kacamata' FA kan opa yg salah, apalagi ditambah ketua FA nya ex chairman City, itung2 kan upaya menggembosi United

[Redsbusby]

ada yg punya statistik hasil United saat ga didampingi SAF ga?

just got this...

Ini Dia Daftar 'Kartu Kuning' Sir Alex Ferguson

KAMIS, 17 MARET 2011 | 10:40 WIB

http://image.tempointeraktif.com/?id=21522&width=490
AP Photo/PA, Nick Potts, File

TEMPO Interaktif, London - Manajer Manchester United Sir Alex Ferguson diganjar larangan mendampingi timnya selama lima pertandingan oleh Asosiasi Sepak Bola Inggris (FA). Menurut The Guardian, sanksi tersebut merupakan yang terberat yang pernah dijatuhkan kepada seorang manajer klub Liga Primer.

Daily Mail menulis, "FA bersikap keras terhadap Fergie terkait omelan ke wasit... dan itu memang sudah waktunya." Sedangkan, Manajer Chelsea Carlo Ancelotti membela Ferguson. Ancelotti menilai sanksi yang dijatuhkan FA terlalu berat.

Sanksi tersebut merupakan yang kesekian kali diterima Ferguson. Berikut ini beberapa sanksi yang dialamatkan ke Ferguson menurut catatan Laurie Whitwell dari Daily Mail.

Oktober 2003. Larangan mendampingi tim di dua pertandingan dan denda 10 ribu pounds (Rp 141 juta) setelah Ferguson mengkritik wasit Jeff Winter saat Manchester United melawan Newcastle United.

Desember 2007. Larangan mendampingi tim di dua pertandingan dan denda 5.000 pounds (Rp 70 juta) setelah Ferguson mengaku bersalah menceramahi wasit Mark Clattenburg di Bolton.

Mei 2008. Ferguson lolos dari sanksi setelah mengkritik wasit Martin Atkinson usai perempat final Piala FA antara Manchester United melawan Portsmouth.

November 2008. Larangan mendampingi tim dua pertandingan dan denda 10 ribu pounds (Rp 141 juta) karena berselisih dengan wasit Mike Dean setelah pertandingan Manchester United melawan Hull.

Oktober 2009. Larangan mendampingi tim di empat pertandingan (dua pertandingan ditangguhkan) serta denda 20 ribu pounds (Rp 282 juta) karena menyebut wasit Allan Wiley tidak fit saat memimpin pertandingan Manchester United melawan Sunderland.

Januari 2010. FA mempertimbangkan untuk mencabut penangguhan larangan mendampingi tim kepada Ferguson setelah Ferguson mengkritik Clattenburg karena mengkartumerahkan Darren Fletcher di Birmingham.

Maret 2010. Ferguson mencap FA 'gila' dan 'tidak berfungsi' karena tidak memberikan sanksi kepada Steven Gerrard setelah Gerrard menyikut Rio Ferdinand. Akibatnya, FA kembali mempertimbangkan untuk mencabut penangguhan larangan terhadap Ferguson.

Maret 2011. Dilarang mendampingi tim di lima pertandingan dan denda 30 ribu pounds (Rp 423 juta) karena mengkritik wasit Martin Atkinson.

Akibat larangan terbaru tersebut, Ferguson kemungkinan bakal absen mendampingi Manchester United pada pertandingan :

1. Sabtu 19 Maret melawan Bolton Wanderers
2. Sabtu 2 April melawan West Ham United
3. Sabtu 9 April melawan Fulham
4. Sabtu 16 April melawan Manchester City di semifinal Piala FA
5. Sabtu 23 April melawan Everton

Jika Ferguson naik banding dan ditolak, larangan kemungkinan bertambah satu pertandingan lagi:
6. Ahad 1 Mei melawan Arsenal


TOTAL DENDA SIR ALEX: 75 ribu pounds (Rp 1 miliar)
TOTAL LARANGAN MENDAMPINGI TIM: 13 pertandingan

[dancoloveunited]

ada yg punya statistik hasil United saat ga didampingi SAF ga?

here it is...

STATS: What Happened In Fergie’s Other Banned Games?

- Played: 8 Won: 6 Draw: 0 Lost: 2
- Before now, he has been banned for 2 games in 2009, 2008, 2007 and 2003.
- With today’s ruling, his fines total £75k.
- Games won: Everton, Portsmouth, Blackburn Rovers, Sunderland, Birmingham City, Leeds United.
- Games lost: v Fulham (1-3 in 2003) and at West Ham (1-2 in 2007)

source (http://therepublikofmancunia.com/stats-what-happened-in-fergies-other-banned-games/)

[Redsbusby]

- Games lost: v Fulham (1-3 in 2003) and at West Ham (1-2 in 2007)[/COLOR]

source (http://therepublikofmancunia.com/stats-what-happened-in-fergies-other-banned-games/)

Upssss...
West ham... bahaya nih... apalagi maen di Upton park :(
Semoga pemainnya masih trauma deh dengan kekalahan di FA..

[Hand_rooney]

2 kali kekalahan lawan fulham dan westham. diantara jadwal dimana SAF harus absen nanti, ada lawan fulham dan westham jg. semoga menang[-O<

[Redsbusby]

Dijatuhi Sanksi Berat, Fergie Ngamuk

Manchester, detiksport - FA telah memberikan sanksi terhadap Sir Alex Ferguson akibat mengkiritik wasit. Usai dijatuhi sanksi tersebut, pelatih Manchester United itu dikabarkan merasa amat marah.

Ferguson dihukum sebanyak lima pertandingan tidak boleh mendampingi MU plus denda sebesar 30 ribu pounds. Sanksi itu diberikan karena dia telah mengkiritik wasit Martin Atkinson yang memimpin laga antara Chelsea melawan timnya beberapa waktu silam.

Akibat skorsing itu, Fergie baru akan dapat kembali ke bench "Setan Merah" pada awal dua bulan depan. Ia akan melewatkan beberapa laga penting termasuk saat melawan Manchester City di semifinal Piala FA pertengahan April dan lanjutan Premier League kontra Arsenal, 1 Mei.

Fergie meyakini dirinya diskors bukan hanya karena memberikan pendapat jujur terhadap Atkinson tapi juga karena salah paham.

"Dia yakin dia cuma memberikan penilaian jujur terhadap penampilan wasit di pertandingan itu. Dia tidak bermaksud untuk mengklaim bahwa wasit sudah bias dan mengoreksi pernyataannya menjadi "adil" dalam wawancara setelah pertandingan," ucap seorang sumber MU kepada The Sun.

"Ia telah menjelaskan dan mempertahankan tindakannya itu dia amat marah karena dia masih menerima hukuman yang begitu berat," tukasnya.

[bucay deathbat]

FA boleh menghalalkan segala cara untuk menggagalkan gelar ke 19 United . .

Tapi United tidak akan menyerah , ,
kami akan buktikan , .

we'll never DIE,we'll never DIE
we'll never DIE,we'll never DIE

we'll keep the red devil flag flying high . .
coz Man Utd will never DIE . .

United > England
United > FA

Not Arogant,Just better !!

United We Stand . .

*Emositingkatiblis

[tumpal_oneunited]

mudah-mudahan bukan pertanda buruk buat skuad Man United..
amin..

[Ucup Carrick]

halah...dari dulu FA kan selalu annoying...
gak heran deh...
pantas aja timnas inggris pecundang mulu....

stupid FA...sama aja kayak PSSI...

[VaDLi]

semoga para pemain ngga terpengaruh ama kasus ini...

kyknya mulai dari FIFA, FA bahkan PSSI banyak ketidak adilan dalam menggelar pertandingan... (terleutama gara" wasitnya)
saat tackle berbahaya hanya mendapat kartu kuning, trus eksekusi pinalti berbuah kartu merah (pogba @ u18 vs liverpool) kayaknya ada yang aneh...
van persie yang (mungkin) ngga denger peluit wasit waktu dia offside, itu juga berbuah kartu merah...
dan banyak lagi kasus lainnya

masih tersisa beberapa pertandingan, nampaknya masih ada kasus lainnya yg akan terjadi...

(akankah FA memakai wasit dari luar inggris??)
http://img.kaskus.us/images/kaskusmobile_hp.gif

[red_devilz]

Wah saya lupa..
seinget saya 2 musim lalu pernah deh, hasilnya seri, lupa...
Mungkin bisa colek red_devilz aja om. biasanya doi hafal klo hal2 beginian :shakehand:


Hahahaha ... udah ada yg jawab tuh :D . Lagian , kmu juga udah posting artikel dr Tempo , Gung :siul: .

Dibandingkan meributkan sanksi utk Fergie , aq lebih khawatir dg krisis cidera yg menimpa lini belakang United . Kompak banget ya , masuk physio room kok janjian [-(

[marsel david]

RIVAL SPEAKS OUT AGAINST SIR ALEX’S 5 MATCH BAN
Posted on Thursday, 17th March 2011
thebusbyway.com


Sir Alex has been left stunned by the 5 match ban and £30k fine handed to him by the FA following comments he made about referee Martin Atkinson following our game against Chelsea earlier this month.
He is yet to decide whether he will appeal against the harsh sanction that will see him miss important games like the City semi final as well as our trip to the Emirates but is clearly disappointed by the course of action the FA took following a disciplinary hearing on Wednesday and he expressed his dismay saying,

“It is disappointing, it is the only industry where you can’t tell the truth. But it is in the past now.”
But Sir Alex isn’t the only person to question the severity of the FA’s decision as again Carlo Ancelotti has spoken out.
The Chelsea boss who also claimed Sir Alex had every right to be angry with Atkinson’s decisions following our game with his side has claimed the FA have acted too harshly in the dealing with Sir Alex saying,
“I think that, my opinion, is that Ferguson has always had good behaviour and I think five games now is too much.
“There is no reason he has to be out for five matches and I do not think that can change their strength and the power of Manchester United.”

[Redsbusby]

Kompak banget ya , masuk physio room kok janjian [-(

:))
Apakah ini pertanda sudah waktunya fergie berjudi layaknya Class of '92 dengan jelmaan Pogba, Morrison, King, Tunnicliffe, dan Norwood?? Who Knows :P

[fredrian.seven]

Aku mbaca di dailymail klo Fergie nerima hukuman itu meski tetap yakin apa yang dilakukan dan dikatakan adalah benar adanya. Tampaknya fergie memilih segera menjalani hukuman akhir pekan ini agar bisa come back pas tandang ke arsenal. Klo fergie banding emang ada kemungkina hukuman dikurangi tapi juga nggak tertutup kemungkinan hukuman bakal ditambah.

Ya udah lah.. Fokus nyiapin tim saat fergie tidak ada dipinggir lapangan ntar.
http://img.kaskus.us/images/kaskusmobile_hp.gif

[The King]

Manchester - Sir Alex Ferguson dijatuhi hukuman dilarang mendampingi Manchester United dalam lima pertandingan. Atas hukuman tersebut, Ferguson merasa kecewa dan tidak terima.

Hukuman tersebut, ditambah denda 30 ribu poundsterling, adalah sanksi yang dijatuhkan FA kepada Fergie atas ucapannya yang mencela wasit Martin Atkinson yang memimpin laga Chelsea vs MU.

Saat itu, Fergie menilai Atkinson merugikan timnya karena tidak memberi kartu kuning kedua kepada David Luiz yang melanggar Wayne Rooney. Dalam pertandingan itu, Atkinson juga menghukum MU dengan penalti serta mengkartu merah Nemanja Vidic.

Vonis skorsing lima pertandingan jatuh dengan rincian skorsing tiga laga untuk kasus ini dan skorsing dua partai lagi adalah hasil dari hukuman percobaan akibat protes Fergie kepada wasit Alan Wiley musim lalu.

Fergie menganggap hukuman tersebut tidak tepat karena ia cuma mengatakan fakta yang sebenarnya. Manajer asal Skotlandia itu juga belum memutuskan apakah ia akan membanding sanksi tersebut atau tidak.

"Ini mengecewakan. Ini adalah satu-satunya tempat di mana Anda tidak bisa mengatakan hal yang sebenarnya. Tapi sudahlah itu sudah berlalu," cetus Fergie seperti dikutip SkySports.

"Saya belum memutuskan perihal banding," tutup Fergie singkat.

(kutipan fr detik.com)

saya sich yakin aja UNITED bisa melewati ujian tanpa Opa

[ario adi nugroho]

Disanksi, Fergie Tak Pertimbangkan Banding

Manajer Manchester United itu kecewa karena perlakuan yang diterimanya.

Sanksi skorsing lima pertandingan yang didapat Sir Alex Ferguson akhirnya menuai tanggapan dari yang bersangkutan. Manajer Manchester United itu mengaku kecewa.

FA memang menjatuhkan sanksi skorsing lima laga untuk Fergie, sapaan akrab Ferguson, menyusul kritiknya terhadap wasit Martin Atkinson usai timnya ditekuk Chelsea 2-1 dua minggu lalu.

Ferguson menilai timnya tidak mendapat perlakuan adil dari wasit yang bertugas kala itu. Dia juga mengkritik keras sejumlah keputusan yang dikeluarkan Atkinson, termasuk kartu merah yang diberikan untuk pemainnya Nemanja Vidic.

Menanggapi sanksi skorsing lima pertandingan, plus denda sebesar 30 ribu poundsterling yang dijatuhkan untuknya, Fergie mengaku kecewa.

"Inilah industri di mana Anda tak bisa berkata jujur. Sungguh mengecewakan. Tapi hal itu sudah menjadi masa lalu sekarang," ungkapnya.

Sedangkan kemungkinan untuk melakukan banding atas sanksi skorsing yang diterimanya ini, Fergie mengaku masih akan memikirkannya.

"Saya masih belum memutuskan untuk melakukan banding," tegas Fergie.


http://www.goal.com/id-ID/news/1108/sepakbola-inggris/2011/03/17/2399143/disanksi-fergie-tak-pertimbangkan-banding

[ario adi nugroho]

Ancelotti: Sanksi Untuk Ferguson Berlebihan

Pelatih Chelsea Carlo Ancelotti berpendapat sanksi skorsing lima partai untuk Alex Ferguson terlalu berlebihan.

Pelatih Chelsea Carlo Ancelotti menunjukkan simpatinya kepada Alex Ferguson, menyusul sanksi skorsing lima partai yang didapatnya.

Pelatih Manchester United itu memang dijatuhi sanksi skorsing dan denda sebesar 30 ribu poundsterling karena kritik pedasnya terhadap wasit Martin Atkinson saat memimpin laga antara Chelsea dan United dua minggu lalu.

Ferguson disanksi karena menilai Atkinson sudah mengambil keputusan yang buruk dan tidak adil.

Ancelotti sendiri sejatinya juga menyesalkan komentar pedas Ferguson itu, namun juga menyayangkan keputusan FA yang terlalu berlebihan dalam menjatuhkan sanksi.

"Saya menilai, menurut pendapat saya pribadi, Ferguson selalu menunjukkan sikap yang baik dan saya rasa skorsing lima pertandingan terlalu banyak," katanya, Kamis (17/3).

"Tak ada alasan mengapa ia harus absen di lima partai dan saya tidak menilai absennya Ferguson akan mengurangi kekuatan dan ketangguhan United."

"Saya juga tahu apa yang dikatakannya usai pertandingan. Memang apa yang dikatakannya bukanlah sikap yang baik, tapi sanksi skorsing lima pertandingan tetap terlalu berlebihan," paparnya.

http://www.goal.com/id-ID/news/1108/sepakbola-inggris/2011/03/17/2398294/ancelotti-sanksi-untuk-ferguson-berlebihan

[tink]

yg saya tau sih harusnya cmn 3 match, tp krn protes wasit lg musim ini kena tambahan 2 ban pendingan musim lalu...
rekor ban untuk pelatih kah?

[Redsbusby]

yg saya tau sih harusnya cmn 3 match, tp krn protes wasit lg musim ini kena tambahan 2 ban pendingan musim lalu...
rekor ban untuk pelatih kah?

yoi gan..
ini rekor terbanyak untuk ban seorang pelatih di Liga Premier...

Sepertinya FA hany ingin memberikan larangan tsb agar fergie benar2 kapok...
karena klo dipikir karena ucapannya, malah ada yg lebih buruk lg,..

[Redsbusby]

Artikel dr Graham Poll. mantan wasit nomer 1 Inggris, mengenai "Seperti apa SANKSI LARANGAN FA KEPADA FERGIE" hingga bagaimana Mourinho semasa di chelsea harus masuk ke dalam keranjang laundry (untuk bertemu pemain di ruang ganti) agar tidak terlihat oleh ofisial UEFA saat terkena Sanksi larangan mendampingi chelsea tahun 2007 :))

Call that a ban? Sir Alex Ferguson still able to have his say despite being absent from the touchline

By Graham Poll
Last updated at 9:55 AM on 21st March 2011

The five-match touchline ban imposed by the Football Association on Sir Alex Ferguson was rightly highlighted as farcical on Saturday.

Television showed Ferguson in regular contact with his assistant manager via an amusingly old-fashioned white phone. All instructions could be conveyed to his team and he could decide on all substitutions.

As the ban is purely as described, a touchline one, Ferguson was also able to give his pre-match talk to his players and even issue last-minute instructions before the team went on to the pitch.

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2011/03/21/article-0-0B3FDC5600000578-329_634x455.jpg
Is that you, Mike? Sir Alex Ferguson issues instructions during Manchester United's clash with Bolton

Then at half-time the Manchester United manager was permitted to go into the dressing room and motivate his players in his own unique fashion, teacups and all.

As they were struggling to break down an excellent Bolton team I am sure that Ferguson would have had plenty to say and work on correcting what he saw as deficiencies.

Recognised as one of the best motivators of players, his absence from that half-time briefing would surely have had an impact on him – possibly enough to really see the FA sanction as a punishment sufficient to cause a change in behaviour.

The way the ban is administered here I struggle to see where the punishment is. UEFA agree with me and impose a far more effective punishment. The coach is barred from the dressing room area from the time that the team sheets have to be submitted, 75 minutes before the kick-off. He is then allowed no contact with the team, or technical area, until after the final whistle. This is monitored by the UEFA match delegate.

Of course there are times when managers appear to have tried to get round this; most famously when Jose Mourhino, during his time at Chelsea, was allegedly smuggled into the changing rooms in a laundry skip!

While I question the accuracy of the story it does show the effectiveness of this type of ban which is why circumvention is attempted.

Back at Old Trafford, as soon as Jonny Evans was rightly dismissed for a poor challenge with excessive force in the 76th minute, Ferguson could be seen instructing his management team on how to organise the 10 men for the final 14 minutes.

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2011/03/21/article-0-0B3F8A2D00000578-413_634x414.jpg
Pure delight: Sir Alex celebrates United's dramatic win

I remember Sam Allardyce revealing that he had even found his enforced absence from the technical area beneficial and started to watch the first half of all games from the directors’ box in the main stand.

A change to the regulation now would be in time for a change for the start of next season and surely the FA must see the need for change if they really do want their punishments to be effective.

[rondwisan]

lama2x udah gak ada lagi kebebasan mengungkapkan pendapat ... :hammer::hammer:
____________________________________

FA explains Fergie punishment
ESPNsoccernet - March 23, 2011


The Football Association has accused Sir Alex Ferguson of undermining the Respect campaign when explaining its decision to hand the Manchester United manager a five-game ban.

Ferguson was given the punishment by an independent regulatory commission, and fined £30,000, following his comments about referee Martin Atkinson in the wake of a 2-1 defeat at the hands of Chelsea at the start of March.

In a post-match interview with MUTV, Ferguson said: "You want a fair referee, or a strong referee anyway - and we didn't get that. I must say, when I saw who the referee was I feared it. I feared the worst."

The commission has now publicised its reasons for hitting Ferguson with the ban, and explained that his refusal to apologise for his comments contributed to the punishment.

It stated: "The commission was referred to Sir Alex's previous disciplinary record, which included several misconduct charges. Although it was his entitlement to do so, he denied the present charge in the face of a strong, if not compelling, case against him.

"Although he denied any intention to question Mr Atkinson's integrity, he should, at the very least, have realised the import of what he said. It follows that any credit to which Sir Alex may have been entitled by admitting the charge, and reduction in sanction, was lost.

"In addition, it follows from his denial of the charge that no clarification or retraction of any of his comments has been made by Sir Alex and no apology given to Mr Atkinson, even after the charge had been brought.

"The commission regarded this as a serious aggravating feature and rejected Sir Alex's case that his use of the word 'fair' was effectively retracted during the interview itself. The commission also took the view that Sir Alex's comments undermined the attempts by the association, through its Respect campaign to encourage higher standards of behaviour within the game, including respect for officials."

[x_ray]

Banding Ditolak, Rooney Tetap Diskors Dua Laga

http://images.detik.com/content/2011/04/07/72/rooney-i.jpg

London - Banding yang dilakukan Wayne Rooney gagal. Akhirnya striker Manchester Untied itu tetap harus menjalani skorsing dua laga.

Seperti dilansir dari Reuters, FA tetap menyatakan Rooney bersalah atas sikapnya usai mencetak gol dalam laga kontra West Ham United akhir pekan lalu. Ia mengucapkan kata-kata kasar di depan kamera televisi.

Dengan berlakunya skorsing itu maka Rooney akan melewatkan laga Liga Inggris akhir pekan ini kontra Fulham dan semifinal Piala FA kontra Manchester City.

"Rooney telah menerima sanksi karena tindakan ofensif, menghina dan atau bahasa kasar namun hukuman dua laga tetap berlaku," bunyi pernyataan FA.

"Komisi tidak menerima klaim itu dan Rooney segera akan memulai skorsing dua laga itu secepatnya. Sanksi ini diberikan menyusul insiden saat laga kontra West Ham United, Sabtu 2 April 2011 lalu," tuntas pernyataan itu.

Sementara itu Rooney mengaku menyesal mendapat skorsing itu. Namun pesepakbola 25 tahun itu menilai jika ia bukan pemain pertama yang melakuna hal ini dan ia menyesali mengapa hanya ia yang terkena hukuman seperti ini.

"Aku menyesal harus absen di dua laga, yang mana salah satunya adalah semifinal Piala FA di Wembley. Aku bukanlah pemain pertama yang mengumpat di depan TV dan juga tidak jadi yang terakhir," aku Rooney di Guardian.

"Aku minta maaf dan sepertinya aku jadi orang yang pertama kali diskorsing karena mengumpat. Itu tidak benar," tutupnya.

sumber (http://www.detiksport.com/sepakbola/read/2011/04/07/170256/1611152/72/banding-ditolak-rooney-tetap-diskors-dua-laga?b99110170)

Nice FA :hajar2:

[derry07cantona]

klo si t*i ini gk diskorsing ya?
mencak2 juga tuh gk dapet penalty
tapi mungkin kagak yah...soalnya ini UCL
wakakaka...

http://img.skysports.com/11/04/800x600/Carlo-Ancelotti-Chelsea-Champions-League-Quar_2582406.jpg

[derry07cantona]

Banding Ditolak, Rooney Tetap Diskors Dua Laga

http://images.detik.com/content/2011/04/07/72/rooney-i.jpg

London - Banding yang dilakukan Wayne Rooney gagal. Akhirnya striker Manchester Untied itu tetap harus menjalani skorsing dua laga.

Seperti dilansir dari Reuters, FA tetap menyatakan Rooney bersalah atas sikapnya usai mencetak gol dalam laga kontra West Ham United akhir pekan lalu. Ia mengucapkan kata-kata kasar di depan kamera televisi.

Dengan berlakunya skorsing itu maka Rooney akan melewatkan laga Liga Inggris akhir pekan ini kontra Fulham dan semifinal Piala FA kontra Manchester City.

"Rooney telah menerima sanksi karena tindakan ofensif, menghina dan atau bahasa kasar namun hukuman dua laga tetap berlaku," bunyi pernyataan FA.

"Komisi tidak menerima klaim itu dan Rooney segera akan memulai skorsing dua laga itu secepatnya. Sanksi ini diberikan menyusul insiden saat laga kontra West Ham United, Sabtu 2 April 2011 lalu," tuntas pernyataan itu.

Sementara itu Rooney mengaku menyesal mendapat skorsing itu. Namun pesepakbola 25 tahun itu menilai jika ia bukan pemain pertama yang melakuna hal ini dan ia menyesali mengapa hanya ia yang terkena hukuman seperti ini.

"Aku menyesal harus absen di dua laga, yang mana salah satunya adalah semifinal Piala FA di Wembley. Aku bukanlah pemain pertama yang mengumpat di depan TV dan juga tidak jadi yang terakhir," aku Rooney di Guardian.

"Aku minta maaf dan sepertinya aku jadi orang yang pertama kali diskorsing karena mengumpat. Itu tidak benar," tutupnya.

sumber (http://www.detiksport.com/sepakbola/read/2011/04/07/170256/1611152/72/banding-ditolak-rooney-tetap-diskors-dua-laga?b99110170)

Nice FA :hajar2:
bukannya wilayah teritorial pers itu diblakang papan iklan yah
kok antek2 si ruper murdoch bebas aja berkeliaran
diarea yang semestinya mereka tidak berada disitu...

kasus2 meludah didepan kamera juga banyak tuh
tapi kok pas rooney aja yang dibanned....

[Redsbusby]

Wah sayangt bgt kudu absen pas lawan city..
yg terpenting absen melawan fulham disaat performanya sedang menanjak...

Arghhh,, FA What?? F**king What?!#$%@$

[RedMachine]

FA S*cks !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
they can ban United Player, but they can't stop united to get the Trophy!!!!!!!!!!

[Vanz Wazza]

FA what??? F***in WHAT!??

special for FA

[red_girl_mia]

bukannya wilayah teritorial pers itu diblakang papan iklan yah
kok antek2 si ruper murdoch bebas aja berkeliaran
diarea yang semestinya mereka tidak berada disitu...

kasus2 meludah didepan kamera juga banyak tuh
tapi kok pas rooney aja yang dibanned....

H E L L FA dan antek anteknya :p #nurdinModeOn

itu namanya syirik om Dery... biarin aja semaunya,namanya juga berkuasa..
United bukan Rooney doank kok. (biarpun saia fans beratnya)
tapi still 19elieve!! we will get the trophy as soon as possible [-O<[-O<[-O<:-bd:-bd

[Redsbusby]

Mengalihkan sorotan ke wasit yang memimpin laga WHU vs Man United...
Semoga saf 'tdk absen di laga melawan arsenal' :hammer:

Fergie - Mason under pressure
United boss believes ref to be in the spotlight after Rooney ban

By Jamie Casey. Footytweets
Last Updated: April 8, 2011 11:25am


http://img.skysports.com/11/03/660x350/110126168_2574090.jpg
Ferguson: Believes Mason is under pressure to punish other players for swearing

Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson has claimed referee Lee Mason is now under extreme pressure following Wayne Rooney's ban for swearing.

Mason was in charge for Manchester United's 4-2 win away to West Ham in which a Rooney hat-trick overhauled a two-goal deficit.

Rooney swore aggressively at a TV camera upon celebrating his third goal, leading to a two-game ban for abusive language from the Football Association.

The England striker lost an appeal to have the punishment reduced, but boss Ferguson believes his squad can use the saga as a 'plus'.

"If he doesn't send a player off for swearing the question will be, has he got double standards?"
Sir Alex Ferguson

Ferguson also switched the attention to Mason, who he believes is now under immense pressure to consistently punish players for foul and abusive language.

"It will bring us together. It is a plus for us. But the one I feel sorry for is Lee Mason. He has put himself in a terrible position," said the Scot.

"He has been put under pressure. There is no doubt about that. It is hard to imagine the referee would send a player off for scoring a hat-trick.

"But he has now put himself in the spotlight. If he doesn't send a player off for swearing the question will be, has he got double standards?

"It is a very difficult position the lad is in. I feel for him. I really do. I don't know where his career is going to go now.

"I think he was put under pressure."

Swipe

Meanwhile, Ferguson hit back at claims from Police Superintendent Mark Payne, who used his online policing blog to condemn Rooney's actions.

Payne, responsible for managing responses to crime and operations in Wolverhampton, wrote: "If Rooney had behaved like that in Wolverhampton on Saturday night, I would have expected my officers to lock him up.

"People in positions of influence have an obligation to behave like human beings. It is not a lot to ask."

Ferguson, though, laughed off the swipe, accusing Payne drawing intentionally attention to himself.

"Everyone has an opinion today," he said. "There is an issue in the modern world of a need to be noticed.

"There is a wee guy, sitting down there in the Midlands, probably never been recognised in his life, managed to elevate himself to whatever it is in the police force.

"Have you ever seen Wolverhampton on a Saturday night? Do police ever arrest anyone for swearing on a Saturday night? Dearie me. That is a good one."

Following Rooney's appeal, Ferguson admits he was not surprised to see the FA uphold their stance on the matter.

"We put an appeal in," he said. "The lad has apologised for swearing but I don't think we expected to get a result."

[fariza]

walaupun rooney ga ada united masih punya berbatov,chicarito dan nani
semoga mereka bisa menggatikan posisi rooney

[sir_otz]

Let see what will FA do about this.... standard ganda ??



http://www.101greatgoals.com/swear-watch-jermaine-beckford-everton-peter-crouch-tottenham/90290/

A week after Wayne Rooney’s foul-mouthed outburst at West Ham, and Manchester United fans want to see if there is any consistency in football.

Leading Red Devils blog the Republik of Mancunia have taken upon themselves to lead a brand new “Swear Watch.” The purpose on this endevour is to flag up incidents of “offensive, insulting and/or abusive language” (i.e. the crime Rooney was found guilty of) in the Premier League.

As explained by the Republik of Mancunia, “No FA rule deals with swearing directly or indirectly at a camera. The rule simply regards using “offensive, insulting and/or abusive language”. One might argue that using ‘offensive, insulting and/or abusive language’ when talking to/shouting at a referee or assistant referee does more damage to the FA’s Respect campaign then swearing at a camera, but that is a matter of opinion.”

After noticing that on the same day that Rooney spat fire down the camera, Liverpool keeper Pepe Reina was spotted mouthing “No way, no f**king way” to referee Martin Atkinson at The Hawthorns, this week’s entries into the swear watch are Everton and Tottenham forwards Jermaine Beckford and Peter Crouch.

Watch the Pepe Reina incident here

http://www.101greatgoals.com/videodisplay/swear-watch-pepe-riena-west-brom-9002853/


In the Saturday lunchtime kick-off between Wolves and Everton, the cameras picked up on fiery argument between Beckford and his boss David Moyes after gaffer subbed the Toffee striker. With the lens capturing the substitution, Beckford was seen mouthing ”f**k me” as his displeasure on ending the game early was all too plain to see.

VacaNZJNL-o

Later, in Tottenham’s 3-2 victory over Stoke, Peter Crouch also was caught swearing all-too-clearly. After putting the Lilywhites ahead, and following his red card at Real Madrid last week in the Champions League, the beanpole striker appeared to exhume some demons as he celebrated his goal by screaming “f*** off” towards the crowd in a moment of jubilation.

Watch the Peter Crouch incident here

http://www.101greatgoals.com/videodisplay/swear-watch-peter-crouch-stoke-9002855/



What!!F*cking What!! .... Opo!!C*k Opo!!...

[VaDLi]

*sigh* udah mo abis musim kompetisi masih aja ngutak-ngutik United... :nohope:

Ferguson charged

Friday, 13 May, 2011

Manchester United manager charged following media comments.


Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson has been charged with improper conduct.

The charge relates to media comments made about match official Howard Webb on 6 May 2011.

Ferguson has until 4pm on 16 May to respond to this charge.

source (http://www.thefa.com/TheFA/Disciplinary/NewsAndFeatures/2011/alex-ferguson-charged-media-comments)

[Redsbusby]

Baru aja gw taruh kursor lampie gw diatas source yg lu kasi nis, gw uda mau muntah ngeliat sourcenya dr THE FA...
Uda opa2 masiiih aja dikerjain.. ckckckc. kualat kualat deh :-L

[VaDLi]

Baru aja gw taruh kursor lampie gw diatas source yg lu kasi nis, gw uda mau muntah ngeliat sourcenya dr THE FA...
Uda opa2 masiiih aja dikerjain.. ckckckc. kualat kualat deh :-L

waduh gw dibilang nis pulak... hahaha
mau dihukum juga kyk opa SAF yaa? :D /:)

sori sengaja itu gw kasih sourcenya biar jelas #EH

[theater of dream]

FA....... :hajar3::hajar3::hajar3:

[Redsbusby]

waduh gw dibilang nis pulak... hahaha
mau dihukum juga kyk opa SAF yaa? :D /:)

sori sengaja itu gw kasih sourcenya biar jelas #EH

#eh om vadli ya, salah sasaran :P
Bukan masalah source-nya (klo itu mah uda bener :) ), cuma gw aja yg eneg om ama kelakuan FA dr dulu gt2 mulu.. orang uda tua gt msh aja dipalakin..ckckck:amazed: