Who's your Reds right-back?

[OA7]

Siapakan yg seharusnya menjadi pemain inti di bek kanan MU yg kurang seimbang dnegan kemampuan EVRA di kiri yg begitu komplit menyerang dan bertahan sama Jagonya


beberapa pertandingan terkahir, sejak G.NEVILLE mulai sering cedera, musim lalu MU seperti nya kesulitan untuk mencari pengganti tetap untuk dimainkan di posisi back kanan

beberapa pemain dipasang di posisi itu

Mulai dari

O'SHEA : Pemain serba bisa, bagus bertahan , kurang bagus menyerang (nurut gue sih)
RAFAEL : Young Star, Hot Prospect, Quick, Skillfull, good in attacking
FABIO : Aslinya bek kiri bisa main dikanan juga, karakteristik mirip Rafael
BROWN : Lumayan ok menyerang dan bertahan, hanya Rentan Cedera
NEVILLE : Paling pas, hanya sekarang sudah berumur dan sering cedera juga, Crossing, tacking mantap.


Siapakah menurut anda yg paling pantas ? apakah MU perlu beli pemain baru diposisi ini ?
apakah mematangkan RAFAEL/FABIO ?


Share your opinion guys




Sorry ya kalau dah ada di close/merge aja : thx

[Mahesa_Jenar]

Leih setuju matangkan Rafael.. Tuh anak dah kelihatan skillnya, jago bertahan jug ajago menyerang. Tipikal Roberto Carlos lah... Udah ada telenta bagus jangan disia-siakan, ntar diambil sama Malaysia lho... hehehehe

tapi sementara ini hanya John the Cat yang paling mantap.. pertahankan Johnny sambil matangkan Rafael...

[finza_13]

menurutku seh untuk posisi Right Back lebih baik kita matengin si Rafael deh,tentunya di luar JOS yg masih tak terganti di posisi itu.

dalam beberapa pertandingan Rafael menunjukkan stamina & fisik yg kuat,bisa nyerang sekaligus bertahan,nah untuk Fabio biarin maen di kiri aja,jaga2 klo evra ga bisa :hammer:

kanan-kiri kembar aseekk juga kayaknya....:siul:

[and1]

yup setuju sm yg di atas, john o'shea saat ini adalah pemaen yg paling pas di posisi RB krn gary & brown sering cedera

tp utk di masa depan rafael & fabio adalah pemaen yg paling tepat mengisi posisi itu, skrg aja mereka dah menunjukan potensi yg bagus, tinggal sering dikasih jam terbang, bakalan mjd 2 bek sayap yg hebat di masa depan

[K3nny_11]

hoho... easy question there from bro TS... jelas dunkk RAFAEL.... O'shea, Brown, not so good in flair, pace, dan membantu serangan, and (sorry) they're not actually a world class player, only decent........ opsi ke 2 baru dehh O'shea, meski pun terkesan medioker, namun performanya lumayan untuk partai big match (nah kalo tuk lawan tim kecil, doi useless :hammer: )..............

[Ucup Carrick]

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_LLUFS9JnqP8/SZT5JcS7vjI/AAAAAAAAAN0/wXqTmaVgbqo/s400/yoichi.jpg

YA-HAA....!!!!

kalo back kanan sih kagak usah dipusingkan...
stok banyak dan melimpah...
paling ancur fletcher ato hargo pun bisa ditempatin di posisi ini...

untuk sekarang..paling bagus untuk posisi ini menurut gua.. ya..RAFAEL!!!!

[hendiplast]

antara Rafael & Fabio
dua pemain ini bs bermain baik di kanan ato kiri
Rafael yg di kanan & Fabio di kiri
tinggal berharap dua pemain di beri jam terbang yg banyak oleh SAF ak yakin mereka bs menjadi bek2 sayap terbaik suatu saat nanti
bs seperti Neville brothers ato mgkn bakal melebihi mereka

[KkingP]

Harusnya sih Wes Brown.. tapi emang dia kurang bisa mengimbangi pergerakan Evra di Kiri.. Rafael mudah2an terus berkembang karena potensinya sangat besar... Mudah2an dia bisa kayak CAFU lah di Brasil...

[rondwisan]

pertanyaan gampang-gampang syusyah nih ..., terutama untuk waktu belakangan ini, di mana Oom Gazza yg musim lalu performanya sempet jeblok, sekarang malah kembali tampil trengginas di postnya ....
__________________________________________________ _______

11/11/2009 10:52 - ManUtd.com, Ben Hibbs
Who's your Reds right-back?

http://picsrv.manutd.com/?fif=/manu/img_10_31823_3385.jpg&obj=iip,1.0&wid=240&hei=359&rgn=0.17741935483870966,0.02066115702479339,0.7741 935483870967,0.7417355371900826&cvt=jpeg

Sir Alex Ferguson has acknowleged that there's a real battle for United's right-back slot, but we want to know who you think should be playing there.

The Reds have as many as six players vying for the position, and all have their merits, according to Sir Alex: "It is a really hotly contested position."

Aside from the senior professionals like Gary Neville, John O'Shea and Wes Brown who have occupied the position on a regular basis in recent years, the Reds have a number of up-and-coming defenders who can fill the roll.

"We've got five or six players who can play there," added the boss. "Rafa da Silva has got great potential to be a top player for us - as has his brother Fabio.

"We've also got Ritchie De Laet who can play there. So we're quite comfortable in that position."

Get involved with the debate by voting in our poll and posting your views on the Talking Reds thread.

Here are some of the best comments we've seen so far:

"It has to be John O'Shea - not because I'm Irish, but because I think he has been one of our best players this season and last."
Posted by Poland 86

"The boss knows best who to play and when to play them. All have their merits. We need all our defenders to be speedy whenever there is a sudden counter attack."
Posted by Man United strikers

"I'd say our long-term right-back is Rafael but he's still the raw diamond. For me, the first-team spot has to be between Nev and Sheasy. O'Shea has been one of the performers of the season while Neville's partnership with Valencia (a Beckham-style winger) has shown glimpses of greatness. The gaffer has a knack for rotating his players, so I think O'Shea and Neville will get 25+ appearances."
Posted by MagicalZidane

"At the moment I'd go for Wes Brown but I think Rafael has to get a look-in too, as he can become one of the great full-backs with more time on the field and on the training ground. That's nothing against O'Shea, who has done a great job all over the defence and in midfield, but for me Brown has the edge on him at right back."
Posted by Champions07-08-09

"Remember this, I tell you Ritchie De Laet is better than the Brazilian twins. He's smooth and can tackle well, has height and strength on them, and he's quick. So he's my pick."
Posted by onimushared

[rondwisan]

klo mo vote ..., silaken segera meluncur ke ManUtd.com


sementara ini sih sebagian besar fans sangat menantikan sosok si kembar Nidji ..., eh Rafael untuk berada di post tsb ..., yah wajar lah ..., emang paling demen nih klo ngliatin doi main ...
so entertain kita semua .... :-bd

ini result sementara poll di ManUtd.com

Who's the right man?

Poll results so far...

Rafael 45%
Wes Brown 23%
John O'Shea 20%
Gary Neville 7%
Ritchie De Laet 3%
Fabio 2%

Figures correct at 14:20 GMT, 11 Nov

link voting : http://www.manutd.com/default.sps?pagegid={C6355B9F-F803-456B-96EA-595F2A784386}&pollid=2306

[fredrian.seven]

Sudah nge-vote opa. pilihan.... Jelas Rafael. Sebenernya bingung antara O'Shea dan Rafael tapi aku rasa duet Rafael dan Valencia bakalan maut,he...

[Tomtom]

entah kenapa SAF belum juga mulai menurunkan rafael/fabio sebagai starter di match2 EPL...
gimana mau lihat permainan duo kribo itu nyetel sama team, kalo jarang di mainkan....sayang talenta besar yang mereka punya...come on SAF!

[hendiplast]

Rafael Da Silva
sebenarny dia udah sembuh blm sih dr cedera?
klo udah, berharap SAF segera menurunkan ny sebagai starter :army:

[Supernan]

Rafael Da Silva
sebenarny dia udah sembuh blm sih dr cedera?
klo udah, berharap SAF segera menurunkan ny sebagai starter :army:

Sama Kita bro Rafael Da Silva :mudance:

Doi udh sembuh bro kan sempet main pas lwn Barnsley di CC waktu itu doi jd starter 90 menit full cmiiw

Mungkin masi ntr" kali yah kalo jd starter soalnya si JOS kan lg konsisten neh /:)

[Sir Alsep Ferguson]

udah vote......wes brown

imo, peran wes brown dalam meng cover gary neville 3 season belakang ini sangat penting

dengan kwartet, wes brown, ferdinand, vidic dan evra
merupakan kwartet pertahanan yang bagus utk merengkuh treble BPL lalu....

sayang nya kali ini, ke tiga pemain tersebut ( minus evra ) sering di dera cidera
sehingga pertahanan united seperti shaky .....

jadi utk saat ini, gw pilih wes brown ahead neville dan oshea .....
gw malah lebih suka kalau fabio atau rafael jadi winger
khususnya fabio ....
gw lihat waktu beberapa kali pertandingan .... insting menyerangnya lebih bagus utk di tempatkan di sektor gelandang .....
gw lupa pas pertandingan apa.....champions kalo gak salah
dia over laping nya mantap banget ....
tiba2 udah ada di area musuh aja berdirinya menyambut umpan jauh ...

[seven7]

kemampuan mereka hampir rata semua...
soalnya gak ada yg paling menonjol..
untuk gary neville, wes brown, oshea dan rafael siapapun yg dimainkan harus sesuai dengan kebutuhan tim menghadapi lawan apa... kalo winger kiri yg punya speed bagus.. gw prefere rafael yg dipake.. walaupun defence nya dia blm bagus banget....
tapi pengalaman wes brown dan oshea patut di kedepankan...

pilihan emang sulit... tapi untuk saat ini wes brown patut di coba buat di pertahankan bermain disisi kanan... karena menurut gw kemampuan dia cukup mumpuni... terlepas dari sering blundernya dia...

untuk rafael.. gw rasa waktunya dia akan datang, kalo dia bisa nunjukin kemampuan bermainnya dia secara penuh dan stabil....

[Jerome Morrow]

Gua juga lebih milih ke Wes Brown..
Rafael bisa jadi back-up dulu, apalagi di sisa partai EPL sekarang United harus bener-bener maksimalin poin..

[theater of dream]

Buat sekarang gw masih pilih Brown...
Posted via Mobile Device

[and1]

utk saat ini gw vote john o'shea, krn selama 2 musim ini dia bisa dibilang tampil konsisten dlm mengisi posisi right back

tp kalo ngomongin masa depan dah pasti gw vote buat rafael krn ini anak pny potensi utk jd pemaen besar

sorry gazza & wes ^:)^

[Mahesa_Jenar]

Pilih Rafael dong...
Untuk masa depan United kayaknya gak perlu repot cari talenta baru. Apalagi lihat penampilannya saat lawan Everton. Kekurangannya cuma satu, dia kurang kuat kalau adu body sama pemain yang berbadan besar. Kalau urusan adu body barangkali hanya johnny O'Shea yang sanggup menghadang lawan segede apapun...

[Supernan]

Rafael Das Silva back in Bussiness!!!! Ga nyangka doi jd starter semalem,gw kira masi blum fit total hehehehe, Young n Agressive Wing Back!!!

[DeJu]

Jhon O'shea, sebagai pelapis dan bek kanan masa depan ya Rafael da Silva.. ;)
Posted via Mobile Device

[bayuyuyayu]

Rafael Da Silva menunjukan aksinya sebagai the next right back....penetrasinya juga sangat membantu UNited hampir setingkat evra tapi he is still the best^:)^

[dekepiks]

vote buat wes brown...

[KkingP]

kalo fit, gw pilih Wes Brown....kedua, baru Rafaelll..
Wes kalo ditaro dikanan, mainnya lebih efektif meskipun dia gak seagresif Rafael.. tp gw lebih aman dengan dia dikanan... karena mungkin pengalaman juga, rafael masih sering out of position..

[derry07cantona]

yup...stuju ama rafael...
tinggal dipoles dikit lagi...

masih sering kecolongan kadang2....

[red_devilz]

Vote for Rafael da Silva ......... Young , Energetic , and Skillfull cuman mesti dibenahi tackle nya ,tuh \m/

[pweechevalier]

Gw urutkan berdasarkan prioritas gw...
JOS22, WB6, RDS21...

wisnu cimol

[gravedigga]

He's big, he's bad, he's Wesley Brown...
He's the hardest man in all the town...
With orange hair beware...
Come and have a go if you dare...

saat ini kombinasi yg terbaik antara skill, pengalaman, mental buat gue sih Wes Brown yah.

[rondwisan]

hihihi ..., ada opsi baru nih ....
Fletcher dan juga Park ... :hammer:

[GUNGZ-HO]

beri jam terbang pada RAFAEL da SILVA O:-)

[theater of dream]

Sebenar nya Hargreves juga sering main sebagai bek kanan, malahan lebih bagus dari Fletcher.... duh kapan bisa main lagi yah??????8->8->8->

[B4YU]

yah klo semua pemaen belakang fit ... pilihan utama masih tetep kepada Brown dan JOS pilihan kedua baru kepada Rafael....:hammer:

klo kondisi spt sekarang dengan Brown sbg CB bersama Vidic ... yah klo Rafael fit berarti pilihan utama kepada Rafael........sebenarnya opsi laen De Laet bagus juga maen sbg bek kanan... tapi keknya SAF belum berani nurunin dia di match "penting" :poys:

[rondwisan]

The Right Back Spot Dilemma?
stretfordendarising.com

http://picsrv.manutd.com/?fif=/manu/img_10_31823_3385.jpg&obj=iip,1.0&wid=240&hei=359&rgn=0.17741935483870966,0.02066115702479339,0.7741 935483870967,0.7417355371900826&cvt=jpeg

Those that have read match preview articles on Stretford End Arising will know the right back spot is often a cause for discussion. For years and years Gary Neville has owned the right back spot. In recent years however he has struggled with injuries allowing others an opportunity to stake a claim. Unfortunately his time as a United player is nearing an end. I’m not writing Neville off completely, but he is unlikely to feature on a weekly basis.

The Options?

With several defenders struggling with injuries last season (Wes Brown, Gary Neville and John O’Shea) Rafael was perhaps thrown in at the deep end. Against Bayern Munich we saw the good and bad of the young Brazilian. Whilst on the pitch he was superb – arguably United’s best player. He gave Franck Ribery a torrid time; he was in the Frenchman’s face from the first minute not allowing him to settle on the ball. His inexperience was highlighted by the sending off, perhaps soft but I felt deserved at the time. He can’t go around kicking players.

A further high profile mistake came against Tottenham Hotspur. The game was his first start since the sending off against Bayern after sitting out a handful of games – an obvious test of his mental strength. Rafael will probably blame himself for not remaining on the goal line, which would have allowed him to clear Ledley King’s header. His reaction to Nani’s goal was special, true emotion and passion!

Mistakes apart, his performances bode well for the future. He will surely will learn from his experiences and mature (in terms of football) more quickly and become a better player. Every player makes mistakes but once he irons out the school boy errors he’s going to be a top class player. As the 2009/10 season ended, I was firmly of the opinion Rafael would establish himself as first choice right back for the forthcoming season. His pre-season form however was somewhat iffy – notably struggling against Kansas City Wizards, which is perhaps a reason O’Shea was preferred.

O’Shea enjoyed his first full season in 2002/03, where he excelled at left-back. He bombed forward at every opportunity earning him the chant “When Johnny goes marching down the wing”. He even nutmegged Luis Figo in one instance. Since then, he has failed to cement a place in the starting as he became Mr. Versatility. Having missed the majority of the 2009-10 season due to injury, it came as a surprise O’Shea started the first Premier League game of the season against Newcastle United – him offering additional height in defensive situations is an advantage.

Would be fair to suggest O’Shea has struggled on his return. However, he is returning after a long term injury therefore to be over critical would be harsh in my opinion. With O’Shea struggling, he has perhaps played a factor in the slow start of the season for Antonio Valencia. Valencia is at his best when he plays alongside an attacking full back – dragging away an opposition defender. At the moment, whether due to the injury lay off and O’Shea finding his feet – he seems reluctant (compared to previously) to overlap. Valencia’s ideal partner is Rafael in my opinion.

During the first half against West Ham, O’Shea visible looked lacking in confidence – struggling defensively. His confidence seemed to grow during the second half – he started to overlap on a more frequent basis. Hopefully his second half performance will give him a boost in confidence

Throughout his career Wes Brown has constantly struggled with injuries and is perhaps a reason why he has never fully cemented a place in the first team. His best season came in 2007-08 when he was relatively injury free and was virtually an ever present a right back. Personally, I believe Brown is a better right back than centre back. If not Rafael, Brown is my preferred choice.

This season Brown is gaining fitness by turning out for the reserves in the Manchester Senior Cup featuring against Manchester City and Oldham Athletic.

What do you think? Should Rafael be first choice right back? Is Sir Alex worried about Rafael’s school boy mistakes? What have you made by the start John O’Shea has made to this season? Due to injuries can Brown be relied upon?

[Wengge Schmeichel]

Vote 21. RAFAEL be starter this season...
Ini pengulangan ketika 2.NEVILLE replace Paul Parker in the mid 1995...
Let Neville as deputy & senior advisor for Rafael this season...itung2 biar jam terbang makin banyak semakin matang...
Then JOS sebagai pelapis selanjutnya...toh JOS bisa any kind of position (RB, LB, DM, CB)
Let Brown be deputy for center back, back up Rio-Vida & Smalling-Evans...