PDA

View Full Version : Manchester United's All-Time EPL Wingers: Nani, Ronaldo, Beckham or Giggs?


zudomiriku
16-02-2011, 10:24 AM
Manchester United's All-Time EPL Wingers: Nani, Ronaldo, Beckham or Giggs?

http://i682.photobucket.com/albums/vv189/zudomiriku/85165775_display_image.jpg

Throughout the illustrious tenure of Sir Alex Ferguson, he has remained steadfast in his belief that United are at their most potent when incorporating a pair of wingers in the side.

While most other clubs have experimented with narrower formations and a more central focus, each of the successful teams constructed by the Glaswegian has featured two wingers who use the vast open spaces of Old Trafford to stretch their opponents.

As a result, the club has seen a proliferation of wing wizards, each of whom are originally compared to George Best and in some special cases plough a furrow all of their own.

Since the original double winning side of 1993-1994, to the treble team of 1999, the three in a row and European Cup winning outfit of 2007-2009, to today’s team who reached February unbeaten and enjoy a healthy four point lead at the top, a plethora of wingers have been talismanic figures in triumphant sides.

But just who is the best winger of modern times?

Let compare the mainstays of each of the sides.

4. Nani
http://i682.photobucket.com/albums/vv189/zudomiriku/108245920_display_image-1.jpg

Rewind the clock 12 months and you’d have gotten long odds on the enigmatic Portuguese being included in this list.

The Champions League quarter final tie against Bayern Munich hinted at a winger who had come of age, and ever since he’s been United’s most consistent threat on the flanks.

Capable on playing on either wing, boasting a compendium of tricks and a decent cross and shot to boot, Nani has been the best winger in the league this season.

Top of the assists chart, Saturdays goal at Wolves took him to eight league goals for the season and if that rate is extrapolated to the denouement of the season, he will further embellish his burgeoning reputation.

3. David Beckham
http://i682.photobucket.com/albums/vv189/zudomiriku/2090567_display_image.jpg

''He cannot kick with his left foot, he cannot head a ball, he cannot tackle and he doesn't score many goals. Apart from that he's all right''. - George Best

George Best might not have thought much of him, but maybe he was just jealous of the first pin up boy to rival the legendary lothario from Belfast.

Despite his failings, (Best actually excluded the most obvious of all, a lack of pace) Beckham was the best crosser in world football during the late nineties and early part of the last decade.

The Cole and Yorke partnership certainly profited from the understanding he forged with Gary Neville down the right flank, and it was also he who swung in those two corners in injury time on that balmy night in Barcelona.

The fact Tottenham recently wanted to extend his Premier League career into a third decade speaks volumes of his professionalism and despite his acrimonious departure he retains a hero’s status at Old Trafford

2. Cristiano Ronaldo
http://i682.photobucket.com/albums/vv189/zudomiriku/zudo%20II/80426657_display_image.jpg

In the summer of 2003, Manchester United needed a replacement for Beckham. None appeared to be forthcoming, but a friendly against Sporting Lisbon uncovered a raw talent.

An 18 year old from Madeira tormented the United defence, and less than a few weeks later he was at Old Trafford. Anyone who hadn’t witnessed the aforementioned friendly wasn’t long in realising United had a special talent on their hands as a late cameo against Bolton was to testify.

His abundance of tricks bamboozled the travelling defence and a star was well and truly born. Ronaldo would finish the season as the club’s player of the year, but it wasn’t until the abdication of Ruud Van Nistelrooy to Real Madrid that the Portuguese really made his mark.

He scored 23 goals as United won the League in 2006-2007 and followed it up with a phenomenal 42 the following year including a goal in the Champions League final.

Even a transfer to Real has done little to besmirch his reputation to United fans, with the club pocketing a world record fee for their troubles.

1. Ryan Giggs
http://i682.photobucket.com/albums/vv189/zudomiriku/108245586_display_image.jpg

There’s been two constants in United’s modern day success, Sir Alex Fergsuon, and Ryan Giggs. Each of the club's Premier League wins have featured the duo, ditto their two modern European Cups and all the other proliferation of trophies they have accrued.

From bursting onto the scene as a 17 year old his talent was obvious, but few could have expected the Welshman to enjoy such a decorated career. Over 800 games for the club have yielded 158 goals with numerous assists and awards to boot. The highlight was probably that goal against Arsenal in the FA Cup semi final replay in 1999 when the treble became a real possibility.

The fact that even at 37, Giggs can still be summonsed to a turn a game on its axis is itself a testament to a unique talent.

His enduring longevity is an example to behold and he stands on a pedestal as Manchester United's number one winger.

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/600092-manchester-uniteds-all-time-epl-wingers-nani-v-ronaldo-v-beckham-v-giggs?utm_source=bleacherreport.com#page/5

rondwisan
16-02-2011, 10:39 AM
Nani ..., hmmm ...
gw rasa masih labil nih anak ...
IMO, blom bisa disejajarkan dengan 3 nama lainnya di atas ..
semoga doi bisa segera ngalahin ego pribadinya deh ..., be your self Nani, kagak usah CR wannabe :peace:

Oom Panda
16-02-2011, 11:20 AM
yeah... Andrei Kanchelskis is waayy better than Nani... but, Nani is progressing.. so, maybe... just maybe... he deserved that 4th spot... ^^

marieme11
16-02-2011, 12:47 PM
Nani ..., hmmm ...
gw rasa masih labil nih anak ...
IMO, blom bisa disejajarkan dengan 3 nama lainnya di atas ..
semoga doi bisa segera ngalahin ego pribadinya deh ..., be your self Nani, kagak usah CR wannabe :peace:

Setuju!
Klo utk saat nama Nani belum 'pantas' lah dimasukin ke list itu..
Itu sih menurut gw yah :)
http://img.kaskus.us/images/kaskusmobile_hp.gif

finza_13
16-02-2011, 01:16 PM
Nani...
masih perlu banyak belajar kerja sama tim,klo pun mau jd CR wanna be..harus banyak belajar shoot deh :sad:

be your self aja lah Nani..... :D

Blacklist7
16-02-2011, 04:30 PM
klo saya... lebih milih urutannya begini :

1. Giggs (status Legend nya kena bgt, sesuai penghargaan all time EPL Winger)
2. Becks (selain status Legend, alasan class of '92 lebih kuat)
3. Ronaldo (ya... cukup pantas nerima penghargaan, karena prestasi singkat nya)
4. Nani (blajar lebih baik kali ya, masuk nominasi dah syukur kok!!)

red_devilz
16-02-2011, 06:11 PM
All Time EPL Winger ??? Of Course ... "Sir" Ryan Giggs :)

Alasannya ??? Loyalitas , Skill , Prestasi , Karisma , Dedikasi , dan sikap yg bersahaja . No doubt about it .

damar
16-02-2011, 08:17 PM
All Time EPL Winger ??? Of Course ... "Sir" Ryan Giggs :)

Alasannya ??? Loyalitas , Skill , Prestasi , Karisma , Dedikasi , dan sikap yg bersahaja . No doubt about it .

TWO THUMBS UP bro. setuju banget tuh, mantep pokoknya. all i wanna meet is HIM. hehee

GL zone
16-02-2011, 09:42 PM
Giggsy... no doubt :D

Redsbusby
16-02-2011, 09:49 PM
Giggsy pastinya...
Bahkan becks sbg satu2nya nomer 7 yg mengoleksi treble masih belom bisa nandingin apa yg dipunya giggsy...

Kagetnya cuma 1, itu nani kok nongol disana ya? nani who? mksudnya sejauh ini belom bangetlah... sbg panutan pun doi msh belom.. masih cukup jauh sepertinya..... harus belajar bagaimana cara agar nggak bikin beberapa orang tiap nnbar selalu aja ada yg nyletuk : sempak :hammer:

renandez
18-02-2011, 10:02 AM
Giggs udh gak perlu ditanya soal permainan dilapangan begitu pun beckham+ronaldo tp kalo nani?
Apa nani udh 1 level dgn trio pemain lainnya?saya kira masih jauh..
http://img.kaskus.us/images/kaskusmobile_hp.gif

becks_nyud_07
01-03-2011, 06:57 PM
aneh juga ada masuk nama nani disana

untuk Gigs memang two thumb untuk dia

layak banyak mendapatkan gelarnya

fickarardana
01-03-2011, 09:05 PM
Hehehe.
Nani masuk. :-)
Yah.. Namanya juga pemilihan.
Semoga Nani bisa belajar dari senior-seniornya.
Biar ga labil.
Untuk 3 nama lainnya udah sip lah.
http://img.kaskus.us/images/kaskusmobile_hp.gif

the seven
02-03-2011, 01:44 AM
nani?
hahahahahahahahahhahahaha
=))=))=))=))=))
bisa aja neh ngelawak

zkadhgn
27-03-2011, 10:15 PM
sebelum memilih saya ingin memberikan pendapat kepada masing2 kandidat!

Nani
pemain ini jelas berbakat, cuma yang disayangkan dari pemain ini adalah terlalu maruk, serakah, walau kadang2 berbuah gol, tetapi sangat sering membuang peluang yang mengakibatkan para penyerang United kesal kepadanya!
mungkin Nani terlalu terfokus ingin menggantikan Ronaldo! :))

Ronaldo
adalah pemain favorit saya, dan saya sangat2 berharap orang ini kembali lagi ke United suatu saat nanti! yang paling layak menggunakan no 7 untuk masa sekarang ini. sepertinya orang ini lebih layak disebut "striker winger" , seorang winger yang memiliki naluri striker yang sangat tinggi! hehe. harus pemain ini kembali ke United! harus!

Beckham
harus diakui ini adalah sayap United yang paling ganteng. hehehe. walau sudah tdk berseragam United, tp semua orang tau hati pemain ini hanya untuk United! :muflag: belum lagi melihat kontribusi dia selama berseragam United!! umpannya, tendangan bebasnya, crossingnya, tendangan setengah lapangnya, tendangan corner di final Champion!! Brilian!

Giggs
pemain dengan bakat fantastis dan dengan loyalitas superb! untuk om Giggs ini slogan yang pas adalah "tua tua keladi, makin tua makin jadi" , benar2 salut dengan umur setua itu, masih mampu bermain 90 menit full! walau sekarang sudah tidak berposisi sebagai winger , cuma kemampuan menggiring bola , passing, crossing pemain ini masih sangat-sangat hebat!

PEMENANGNYA adalah
Ryan Giggs! secara teknik jelas kalah dari Ronaldo, tapi untuk masalah emosi-pengalaman-loyalitas pemain ini jelas lah seorang yang p[aling pas menjadi pemenang winger terbaik United sepanjang masa!

:muflag::muflag::muflag:


menurut saya sih Giggs, karena udah bisa dipastikan loyalitas thdp United nya!
tp saya selalu berharap Ronaldo bakal balik lagi ke United! hehehe

J.co
27-03-2011, 10:51 PM
winger yang selalu haus gol...dengan kecepatan dahsyat dan tendangan yg keras,postur tubuh yg ideal dengan bola bola atas,free kick yg luar biasa ditambah dengan gocekan mautnya dan ambisiusnya dia selalu menjadi pemain terbaik yang pernah dimiliki united..:D

namun bicara loyalitas dan kepribadian seorang pemain jelas pemilik no punggung 11 lah yang perlu diacungi jempol..

bagi saya winger terbaik sepanjang masa hanya Ronaldo dan giggs :>

khie
12-04-2011, 02:57 AM
wahh..

klo Beckham masuk lah winger yg patut diperhitungkan,pas dulu masih kecil tendangan bebas + umpan2 beckham sampe ada istilah "bukan orang yg nyari bola,tp bola yg nyari orang"..
klo Ronaldo, permainannya mungkin salah satu yg terbaik pas di United,penetrasinya "ich wow"..
klo Giggs,jelas gk perlu diragukan lagi,loyalitas,permainannya bener2 seperti bukan pemain yg berumur kepala 3..
nahhhhh..,klo nani ya mungkin masih nunggu ibarat kata "nunggu bunga lg mekar" *semoga mekar*..

:muscarf::muscarf::muscarf:

lee martin
14-04-2011, 10:47 PM
Giggsy pastinya...
Bahkan becks sbg satu2nya nomer 7 yg mengoleksi treble masih belom bisa nandingin apa yg dipunya giggsy...

Kagetnya cuma 1, itu nani kok nongol disana ya? nani who? mksudnya sejauh ini belom bangetlah... sbg panutan pun doi msh belom.. masih cukup jauh sepertinya..... harus belajar bagaimana cara agar nggak bikin beberapa orang tiap nnbar selalu aja ada yg nyletuk : sempak :hammer:

hahahaha
kadang" terlalu sisimaruk.

theater of dream
14-04-2011, 10:51 PM
Baru nyadar ternyata Nani masuk juga yah ...... =))

arwi27
23-04-2011, 04:43 AM
Milih Giggs (wow)
Giggs punya hampir segala hal yg dibutuhkan utk menjadi winger legenda united (malah udah B-)), loyal, dedikasi dan determinasi yg tinggi, berstamina layaknya kuda (hahaha). Assist2 dari kaki kirinya "wuih dan hal lainnya ga bisa diremehkan bahkan di juluki "Raja Tendangan Kaki Kiri" CMIIW. Ada pepatah yg cocok buat oom giggs (maklum saya masih muda :malu) "Tua-tua makin jadi". Yang cocok dsematkan padanya(umur 37, masih kuat jdi salah satu motor serangan united)
:muscarf:

Rank
1. Giggs
2. Ronaldo
3. Beckham
4. Nani

MUFC1878
23-04-2011, 02:59 PM
giggs...theres only one name is giggs


kalo mau ngomongin masalah yg terbaik, ter legend, ter -apa sih


cm GIGGS 11 :thumbup:

ferly_Liemz
23-04-2011, 03:14 PM
Wah kl ada nama giggs ya ud pasti giggs dunk... Best Winger in the world...
http://img.kaskus.us/images/kaskusmobile_hp.gif

adefebsa
23-04-2011, 04:18 PM
Nani?gak salah?
Dy klo saya liat selama ini masih labil.maruknya itu naujubile...
Aneh jg kalo namanya masuk disana...
http://img.kaskus.us/images/kaskusmobile_hp.gif

and1
24-04-2011, 05:04 PM
menurut saya sih pd jaman jayanya, Andrei Kanchelskis jg layak masuk list ini, mgkn sedikit di atas Nani, tp Nani msh akan berkembang, smoga kelak bisa mjd pemain yg lbh matang, bagus & tdk egois

Giggs pasti ada di urutan teratas, Ronaldo no 2, kemudian Beckham, versi saya Kanchelskis ada di no 4, br Nani :D

eMJi_197
24-04-2011, 05:50 PM
Ryan Giggs lah pastinya
selamanya di UNITED dan produk asli binaan UNITED
Beckham layak ada diurutan kedua...
produk asli dan sudah memberikan gelar treble :D

marsel david
24-04-2011, 08:02 PM
ya undah tentu Giggs ada di paling atas,,
keduanya Becks

and setuju sama mas Andi Andrei Kanchelskis jg layak masuk list
jadi no 4 nani no 5

Shrek10
16-05-2011, 02:36 AM
Giggs memang pantas di no 1, tapi Nani, saya rasa dia masih mencoba untuk menjadi 'Ronaldo' :D

p4cul
17-05-2011, 06:36 PM
beckham dan giggs
nama nani coret aja,malu2in