PDA

View Full Version : Manchester United - Dream Team


rondwisan
07-08-2009, 08:48 AM
pasti masing-masing orang punya team impiannya sendiri nih ..., dah gak usah pake debat deh ..., just share Urs 'n other source aja yaa .... :peace:
__________________________________________________ _____

Manchester United dream team -
no place in squad for Giggs, Ronaldo, Stam, Scholes or Keane
belfasttelegraph.co.uk, Chosen by Jimmy Leach - 12 July 2009


They may be the World, European and English champions but just one of the current crop make it into the Manchester United dream team.

There is no room for Giggs, Ronaldo, Stam, Scholes or Keane - testament to the quality that has passed through Old Trafford over the years.


http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00115/schmeichel_115501s.jpg
PETER SCHMEICHEL Goalkeeper
Manchester United, 1991-199, 292 appearances United have a patchy record with goalkeepers for some reason and for every Harry Gregg or Edwin van der Saar, there's been a Chris Turner or a Gary Bailey. Not dreadful (Taibi) but not always top notch. Schmeichel tops them all. Physically intimidating, his athleticism could be astonishing, his willingness to improvise equally so - as his dignity-shredding star-jump saves would attest. Life threatening to defenders as well as opposing strikers, he was clearly barking, but unarguably the best goalie the Premiership has seen.

http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00115/neville_152230s_115521s.jpg
GARY NEVILLE Right back
Manchester United, 1992-present, 376 appearances, 5 goals Yes, Gary Neville. The Scouse-baiting barrack-room lawyer. The man who can't grow a beard. He's never been one of United's most popular players, but as England's most-capped right-back and a career which virtually spans United's most glorious years, he may just be a better player than many give him credit for. An astute defender, he forged an impressive partnership down the right wing for club and country with David Beckham, but after Beckham left for Madrid, Neville worked harder and became the most consistent crosser of a ball in the side.

http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00115/buchan_152228s_115523s.jpg
MARTIN BUCHAN Centre back
Manchester United, 1972-83, 456 appearances, 4 goals No Ferdinand? Stam? Foulkes? Buchan is perhaps the hardest to justify but he oozed class and vision in some rather patchy United sides - suffering relegation in 1973 and winning the FA Cup in 1977. A smooth operator and disciplined defender he kept himself, and his team, to the highest personal standards - once cuffing errant winger Gordon Hill around the head for having the effrontery not to mark up for a throw in. And when asked for a 'quick word' by a journalist, settled for 'velocity' before walking off.

http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00115/irwin_152229s_115522s.jpg
DENNIS IRWIN Left back
Manchester United, 1990-2002, 368 appearances, 22 goals Much is made of Sir Alex Ferguson's spending, but many of his best signings were absolute bargains. A mere £625,000 secured the Irishman from Oldham (who, even more pleasingly had taken him on a free from Leeds) and his prowess at right and left back earned him the faint praise of 'dependable'. He was much more than that. Great crosses and free kicks, huge energy up the flanks and quicker than he looked (though he looked like a bank clerk). Mick McCarthy, the chump, ended his international career for Ireland when he dropped him and told him to 'go out and prove himself'. He already had - hundreds of times.

http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00115/edwards_152227s_115524s.jpg
DUNCAN EDWARDS Centre back
Manchester United, 1953-58, 151 appearances,20 goals Played more of a midfield role for the Busby Babes but, had he lived, he would most likely have been the sort of ball-playing centre-half that could have kept Bobby Moore out of the England team in 1966. In his five brief years of professional football, he became the youngest player to turn out for England and won two league titles before his death in the days after the Munich air disaster. Bobby Charlton rated him as 'the only player who made me feel inferior' - and he included George Best and Pele.

rondwisan
07-08-2009, 08:53 AM
lanjut ....

http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00115/robson_152226s_115525s.jpg
BRYAN ROBSON Centre midfield
Manchester United, 1981-1994, 345 appearances, 74 goals Separate in your mind Robson the manager from Robson the player. In the eighties he dragged both England and United by the scruff of the neck, as under Ron Atkinson and then in the early years of Ferguson's era, United were cup specialists. His all-action style left him increasingly fragile but when fit and on form he possessed all the drive of Roy Keane with the added ability to score crucial goals without chasing personal vendettas.

http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00115/charlton_152225s_115526s.jpg
BOBBY CHARLTON Centre midfield
Manchester United, 1954-1973, 606 appearances, 199 goals Renowned now as a gentleman off the pitch but reputedly a grumpy customer on it, he nevertheless transformed himself from a top-class winger into the world's best central midfielder during his finest years. He lifted the World Cup (1966), the European Cup (1968) and was named European Footballer of the year following England's World Cup success. Raking passes, a booming shot, glorious goals and a preposterous comb-over made him one of the most recognisable players on the planet.

http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00115/best_152224s_115527s.jpg
George Best
just BEST

http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00115/beckham_152223s_115529s.jpg
DAVID BECKHAM Right midfield
Manchester United, 1993-2003, 361 appearances, 62 goals For the right wing slot, it is a choice between show-ponies: Beckham or Ronaldo? Either graces a billboard as well as the pitch but Beckham edges it for the unerring quality of his crossing, his under-rated hard work up and down the flank (at his peak at least) and the greater reliability of his free-kick taking.

http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00115/cantona_152222s_115530s.jpg
ERIC CANTONA Striker
Manchester United, 1992-1997, 144 appearances, 64 goals There have been more skilful forwards (Rooney?) and more prolific (van Nistelerooy?) but no-one has made things happen quite so dramatically. The barren years without a title ended as Eric arrived, collar-up, shrugs at the ready to instil self confidence, imagination and a succession of vital goals - including the winner to clinch the Double against Liverpool in the 1996 FA Cup final. In the middle of all that, there was the odd kerfuffle, including the kung-fu kick on a Crystal Palace fan, but it all added to the mystique...

http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00115/law_152221s_115532s.jpg
DENIS LAW Striker
Manchester United, 1962-1973, 309 appearances, 171 goals Not many can survive the legend of relegating United (with his backheel for City in 1974, though the Reds were already doomed by then), but his style, skill, courage and impudence made him a hero. For Busby he was the 'quickest thinking player I've ever seen ' and his reflexes were astonishing - the first to leap, flick or scissor-kick the ball speeding across the six-yard box. A scrawny runt of a player with a squint, he was still the best player Scotland has ever produced.

K3nny_11
07-08-2009, 10:31 PM
what a fine piece of article.......... really enjoy reading this...........

but why oh why GIGGS ga masuk list ?? :crazy:

Anderstone
08-08-2009, 01:39 AM
belfasttelegraph.co.uk

hehehehe

tumpal_oneunited
08-08-2009, 02:55 AM
Gw kurang familiar dengan nama Martin Buchan di posisi centre back MU.. :peace:
Yo weez..gapapalah ga ada Rio, Stam, Bruce, Pallister..
Namanya juga pendapat...

Mahesa_Jenar
09-08-2009, 01:59 PM
Bukannya Edwards posisinya Midfielder kayak Paul Scholes..? kok jadi center Back..? ini sengaja atau cuma maksain biar Edwards bisa masuk..?
Lagipula masa Sir Bobby duet sama Robson, keduanya punya tipe yang sama kan..?
Well.. tapi pilihan masing maisng orang beda-beda sih...

marsel david
09-08-2009, 05:01 PM
MARTIN BUCHAN Centre back
ni siapa ya... baru denger banget ni gw namanya....
btw kenpa gigss ga ada ya....:crazy:

alfrina
09-08-2009, 05:20 PM
MARTIN BUCHAN Centre back
ni siapa ya... baru denger banget ni gw namanya....
btw kenpa gigss ga ada ya....:crazy:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Buchan

gw jg baru denger ... wajar sih, dia ninggalin MU thn 83 ... ge aja blom lahir ... hehehehe ...

sm kaya yg lainnya ... kok giggs bisa ga masuk ya ??

:confusing::confusing::confusing:

youngtimer48
09-08-2009, 05:23 PM
harus buka2 sejarah United lagi nih tentang Martin Buchan.. hehehe..:happy:

angga_depitianto
10-08-2009, 04:19 AM
emang bryan robson ama giggs jagoan robson yaa??
gue masih terlalu belia buat ngeliat robson maen di united...
waktu gue mulai nonton EPL doi udah maen di boro,,,
jadi kurang tau deh,,,
hehhehe..

rondwisan
10-08-2009, 08:44 AM
what a fine piece of article.......... really enjoy reading this...........

but why oh why GIGGS ga masuk list ?? :crazy:

klo dream teamnya Oom Giggs sendiri nih ...

GK : Schmeichel - VDS (katanya bingung milih cuman 1)
Defender : Gary Neville - Jap Stam - Rio Ferdinand - Denis Irwin
Midfield : Beckham - Keano - Scholes - Giggs
Forward : Cantona - Rooney

source :
http://www.thespoiler.co.uk/index.php/2009/05/20/ryan-giggs-leaves-ronaldo-out-of-his-man-utd-dream-team

juliand_fergie
10-08-2009, 10:06 AM
kayanya alesan giggs ga masuk karena ada George Best disana..
well, as you all know.. George Best yaa... kya yg di artikel aja, just BEST..
naah, tapi kenapa ga ada keane yaa?
apa Robson lebih yahuud dari Keano? :amazed:

Anderstone
10-08-2009, 11:57 AM
kayanya alesan giggs ga masuk karena ada George Best disana..
well, as you all know.. George Best yaa... kya yg di artikel aja, just BEST..


itu karena yg bikin belfasttelegraph.co.uk, klo yg bikin northwalespioneer.co.uk, mungkin hasilnya beda.

finza_13
10-08-2009, 12:17 PM
klo dream teamnya Oom Giggs sendiri nih ...

GK : Schmeichel - VDS (katanya bingung milih cuman 1)
Defender : Gary Neville - Jap Stam - Rio Ferdinand - Denis Irwin
Midfield : Beckham - Keano - Scholes - Giggs
Forward : Cantona - Rooney

source :
http://www.thespoiler.co.uk/index.php/2009/05/20/ryan-giggs-leaves-ronaldo-out-of-his-man-utd-dream-team

weww......emang yg paling membingungkan di posisi GK..ampe' Om Giggs aja harus milih dua pemain senior itu.....:peace:

rondwisan
10-08-2009, 12:53 PM
itu karena yg bikin belfasttelegraph.co.uk, klo yg bikin northwalespioneer.co.uk, mungkin hasilnya beda.

yupie ..., makanya gw tulis juga tuh, ini khan pandangan subjective dari satu penulis aja ...
klo liat versi Oom Giggs juga rada-rada piyee gitu khan Sob ... hehe ...

tapi emang yang jelas karena United dah kebanyakan 'Legend' kadang kita sering syusyah juga nentuin best of the best-nya untuk masing2x posisi, apalagi untuk para former nyang dah lama sekali, era di bawah 80-an bahkan 70-an
(makanya pilihan United XI temen2x United Indonesia ama temen2x IndoManUtd kmrn bisa laen, blom lagi nyang jadi komentator para senior player gitu, meski gak yakin juga mereka pernah liat pemain2x United tempo doeloe :hammer: )

ecly_watchaa
10-08-2009, 01:19 PM
klo dream teamnya Oom Giggs sendiri nih ...

GK : Schmeichel - VDS (katanya bingung milih cuman 1)
Defender : Gary Neville - Jap Stam - Rio Ferdinand - Denis Irwin
Midfield : Beckham - Keano - Scholes - Giggs
Forward : Cantona - Rooney

source :
http://www.thespoiler.co.uk/index.php/2009/05/20/ryan-giggs-leaves-ronaldo-out-of-his-man-utd-dream-team

yep..

semalam jg liat neh beritanya di tv swasta...
doi binun di posisi kiper hehe....lini belakang
pilihan om Giggsy ajib bgt dah tuh,..

Lidya_Manutd_10
12-08-2009, 08:27 PM
Buset United emank mantep bahkan ga ada tempat buat pemain terbaik dunia 2008...he3...tp becks pantes sih masuk dream team
Rooney jg ga masuk yah??wah2...bener2 nih level dream teamnya UNITED....

Tapi aneh jg klo duncan edwards masuk dream team...memank dia pemain hebat tp kan dia bermain blum terlalu lama