United Indonesia - Manchester United Indonesia Supporters Club - Rooney is not a world class player yet...

United Indonesia - Manchester United Indonesia Supporters Club (http://www.unitedindonesia.org/forum/index.php)

- Debate Room (http://www.unitedindonesia.org/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=57)

- - Rooney is not a world class player yet... (http://www.unitedindonesia.org/forum/showthread.php?t=964)

Rooney is not a world class player yet...

Quote:

Wayne Rooney still short of elite trio, says United's manager

Sir Alex Ferguson challenges the 23-year-old to match the world's top three players

Manchester United's English forward Wayne Rooney takes part in a training session

Five years to the week since Wayne Rooney announced his arrival at Manchester United with a Champions League hat-trick against Fenerbahce, the England international will make his 50th European appearance tonight, with Sir Alex Ferguson challenging him to show that he can reach the levels of Cristiano Ronaldo, Kaká and Lionel Messi.

Rooney has scored seven in nine games for United this season and has noticeably taken on more responsibility since the departure of Ronaldo but Ferguson, though generous in his praise, believes his striker still comes up short. "Kaká, Ronaldo and Messi are the best three at the moment and I think Wayne can get to that level if he keeps making progress," he said. "That's the challenge for him now. There are some great players there."

There are some United supporters who would argue that Rooney already deserves to be considered at that level but Ferguson is mindful of the fact that the 23-year-old has sometimes drifted out of matches. "Wayne has had some fantastic games in Europe and, to be honest, some disappointing games," he added. "European football is a challenge. These are the best teams and every player has to reach that challenge in the sense of [creating] their stature in the game. It's not an easy competition."

By that, Ferguson was highlighting the fact that Ronaldo, Messi and Kaká have flourished in the Champions League whereas Rooney has been more erratic. In total, he has scored 16 European goals going into the game at home to Wolfsburg, the German champions regarded by Ferguson as "probably the main danger to qualifying".

However, Ferguson also pointed out that Rooney is still not in his peak years. The United manager remembered Rooney's debut, in a 6-2 win, as a "remarkable feat", not least as the player had been injured and not played for 10 weeks. "His progress has at no point disappointed us," he said. "When we signed him as a kid we thought he would become a really top player and he is going in that direction, without question. He is blessed with certain ingredients that only great players have. He has that hunger and determination.

"Roy Keane, Bryan Robson, Steve Bruce – we have had countless players with that great desire. These players want to win every match and every training session. Wayne is blessed with that and that will never change. He is blessed because these are wonderful things to take into a game these days. You sometimes wonder about the criticism about the money players get but then when you look at the amount of effort Wayne puts into his work then he is worth every penny. He plays as if he means it and it's a wonderful thing to have.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2...nited-ferguson

Saya buat thread ini untuk mengetahui komentar teman2, mungkin banyak yang tidak setuju dengan artikel ini,
As the article says, he isn't in his peak, Elite Trio, Ronaldo, Kaka, Messi and Rooney isnt there yet...
However he is our best player and very important for us..
Apakah pernyataan SAF memang Objective atau sekedar pemacu semangat Rooney saja buat dia lebih tertantang?
Who knows....
Please give your factual opinion..........

Re: Rooney isnt in world classy player yet...

Rooney terlalu moody... he's great, but, he's moody...

3 match terakhir doi cepet banget ilang konsen...mungkin faktor Colleen mau ngelahirin kali yah....

But, i think Rooney doesnt care whether he's a world class or not.. dia cuma mau maenin sepakbolanya dia dan memberikan yang terbaik buat Manchester United. He unlike Ronaldo, not chasing all that fame and individual records. (menurut gw loh)...

But, to me... YUP.. He's already proof that he is a WORLD CLASS player....

Re: Rooney isnt in world classy player yet...

yg ini udah kynya kmaren...hehehe cb periksa lg di thread lain y bro...:peace::peace:

Re: Rooney isnt in world classy player yet...

Quote:

Originally Posted by red_girl_mia (Post 44652)

yg ini udah kynya kmaren...hehehe cb periksa lg di thread lain y bro...:peace::peace:

yang mana sist ?

Re: Rooney isnt in world classy player yet...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oom Panda (Post 44651)

Rooney terlalu moody... he's great, but, he's moody...

3 match terakhir doi cepet banget ilang konsen...mungkin faktor Colleen mau ngelahirin kali yah....

bener Oom mungkin faktor Colleen yang mau melahirkan nyita banyak konsentrasinya Roo di lapangan..

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oom Panda (Post 44651)

But, i think Rooney doesnt care whether he's a world class or not.. dia cuma mau maenin sepakbolanya dia dan memberikan yang terbaik buat Manchester United. He unlike Ronaldo, not chasing all that fame and individual records. (menurut gw loh)...

But, to me... YUP.. He's already proof that he is a WORLD CLASS player....

setuju banget Oom....
mungkin yang paling penting bagi Roo adalah memberikan yang terbaik buat United ga
tanpa peduli gelar perseorangan seperti pemain terbaik dunia

Re: Rooney isnt in world classy player yet...

Quote:

Originally Posted by marsel david (Post 44663)

bener Oom mungkin faktor Colleen yang mau melahirkan nyita banyak konsentrasinya Roo di lapangan..

setuju banget Oom....
mungkin yang paling penting bagi Roo adalah memberikan yang terbaik buat United ga
tanpa peduli gelar perseorangan seperti pemain terbaik dunia

Indeed, my friend... ^^

Dia selalu mencoba memberikan yang terbaik untuk United...

Re: Rooney isnt in world classy player yet...

Rooney said his best position is up front...

IMO He is better play behind the front, that way he can influence the midfield more and link it to the attack better...

Re: Rooney isnt in world classy player yet...

Kl dinilai performanya Rooney selama ini gw setubuh, Rooney berpotensi besar namun memang blm sampai pd tingkatan yg di ungkap oleh SAF... Tp kembali lg, yg salah dmn? Penempatan posisi, duet dan teammates atau Rooney dlm artian mental dan konsistensi? Gw rasa smuanya lah ya... Posisi sering berpangaruh bg Rooney contohnya kita tau Rooney bukanlah tipe striker tunggal namun baik SAF dan Capello sering menempatkannya pd posisi tersebut dia akan lbh sbg striker behind the front seperti yg dikatan bro diatas (theater of dream), lalu terkadang Rooney terlihat membutuhkan duet atau pemain yg bs benar2 tune in dgnnya meski ga mencetak goal namun dia bs membackup pemain utk menciptakan peluan goal seperti duetnya dgn CR, lalu seperti yg bro Athma blg Rooney sering kehilangan konsentrasi bahkan menjurus frustasi ntah karna mental atau sifatnya yg moody hingga sgt berdampak pd performanya hal ini terjadi berkali kali baik di United maupun timnas England...

Hanya pada SAF lah kita bs berharap agar potensi Rooney lbh maksimal dan dpt memperbaiki mentalnya agar lbh fokus dan berharap potensinya bisa sukses seperti CR. Setubuh lg dgn bro diatas, Rooney merupakan pemain terbaik United musim ini dan jelas United akan sgt bergantung padanya. Menurut gw apa yg dikatakan oleh SAF diatas selain utk membuat Rooney terpacu jg kesadaran SAF dlm menilai Rooney blm maksimal hingga ini dan akan yg terbaik akan Rooney segera hadir.

Re: Rooney isnt in world classy player yet...

gua yakin...mungkin inilah rasanya jadi calon seorang ayah yah...
gelisah gimana gitu sampe emosi gak terkendali...
gua yakin saat punya anak nanti...
Rooney will be more dangerous!!!!
he's got an inspiration to do more!!!!

:army:

Re: Rooney isnt in world classy player yet...

World Classy apaan sih?