United Indonesia - Manchester United Indonesia Supporters Club
Register
Go Back   United Indonesia - Manchester United Indonesia Supporters Club > OUTSIDE UNITED > Debate Room

Old 15-04-2010, 11:10 AM   #1
Oncy
Founder
-
 
 
Oncy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 891
Thanks: 140
Thanked 172 Times in 86 Posts
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Oncy Ready for being a real United Indonesia


Default Carrick lack of performa (started page 8)

Sekedar ingin meramaikan debate aja di forum, maklum sdh lama jg ga bikin thread debate...

Menarik nih, lg hot2nya di bahas di forum/site luar... Oleh fans Man.United sendiri di cap "biasa saja" bahkan banyak juga yg menganggap "flop" meski dengan hadirnya Carrick United telah memenangi 3 EPL, 1 UCL dan 2 Carling dll... Ditambah sekarang banyak yg memperdebatkan apakah Carrick pantas untuk tampil di PD 2010 Afsel nanti bergabung dengan squad Capello... Knapa dianggap biasa saja? Karna sejujurnya posisinya Carrick itu kurang jelas, asli Center Midfield namun tidak jelas lebih condong sbg defensive or offensive? Nah dalam kedua hal tadi Carrick dianggap biasa saja karna tackle kurang, agresive biasa saja, passing pun jg dianggap biasa saja, lalu speed n visi permianan jg biasa, shooting dan headingnya pun terbilang standard, nah kelebihannya apa? Kl dari berbagai pendapat kelebihannya hanya dia bisa mudah nyetel di lini tengah meski konstribusi dan pengaruhnya nya ga terlalu dominan...

Gw tidak mau menarik kesimpulan terlebih dahulu, namun gw ingin mengetahui dan share opini dan pendapat teman2 mengenai hal ini...

Ini gw masukin artikel mengenai Carrick dr football pundit beserta comment akan artikel tersebut...

Quote:
Carrick key for club and country

Michael Carrick has come in for some heavy criticism of late but TEAMtalk's Ian Watson believes he remains a key man for club and country.

Everyone loves a scapegoat, and with Manchester United's season having come pretty spectacularly off the rails over the past fortnight, few at Old Trafford are escaping the backlash.

Dimitar Berbatov and Sir Alex Ferguson are copping most of the blame, but Michael Carrick is coming in for some extremely heavy stick, pretty unreasonably it seems.

Granted Carrick, like many of his team-mates, has not enjoyed his most productive season but the midfielder still has a key role to play for club and country, one with different responsibilities than those he was given during his first three years at Old Trafford in which he won a title-winners medal in each.

Carrick has been employed in a slightly more defensive role for United this campaign, even at times being asked to drop back in at centre-half. As a 'water-carrier', Carrick's discipline has allowed Darren Fletcher to continue carving out a reputation as a box-to-box player, while veterans Paul Scholes and Ryan Giggs have been allowed to concentrate more on supplying the front men.

Because he has become less of an attacking influence, many United fans have been quick to identify Carrick as one of the reasons their season has stalled, with some even wanting him sold.

Those fans might then be surprised at just how important Carrick could be to England's World Cup campaign this summer.

Fabio Capello has used Gareth Barry as the more defensively-minded midfielder during their successful-but-untesting qualification campaign, but in South Africa, especially at the later stages of the tournament, Barry is likely to need a hand. Something he gets at club level from Nigel De Jong, Vincent Kompany or Patrick Vieira.

The Manchester City man has been in the side largely because of his ability to influence the play at both ends of the field but against the best teams in the world, Barry could find himself exposed defensively and out-numbered. The inclusion of Carrick - with his tactical nous and passing radar - gives England an insurance policy in a system that relies on attacking full-backs and the ability of Frank Lampard and Steven Gerrard to get forward in support of Wayne Rooney and Emile Heskey.

Carrick might not be seen as the glamorous option ahead of a speed merchant such as Aaron Lennon, and in the group stages, the midfielder's industry may well give way to a more obvious attacking threat. But as the tournament goes on or perhaps in the later stages of games during which England find themselves under the cosh, Carrick may play an increasingly important role.

For precedents, one only has to look at the 2002 and 2006 tournaments, during which Nicky Butt and Owen Hargreaves respectively were England's star men ahead of their more attacking and attention-grabbing peers.

Before their performances proved the doubters wrong, Butt and Hargreaves also had their England places questioned, with Hargreaves actually being booed by those who failed to recognise his contribution. Sounds quite similar to Carrick's current circumstances, don't you think?

Without doubt, had Hargreaves managed to overcome his injury and psychological issues, he would be the anchor man for United and England.

But with his return seemingly no nearer than at any point over recent months and United having more pressing demands on their limited transfer budget, Carrick remains the best alternate option for both Ferguson and Capello.
Comment :

Quote:
diarmuid_ger (Manchester United): this article says carrick will be vital against the better opposition...the player is completely out of his depth against the top sides..hence why united fans want rid. He is a decent player against the lesser lights of the premier league, but he has been a nothing player in big european games since he came to the club. His tactical nous and passing range??? this myth that carrick is such a wonderful passer annoys me. please look at the same games as the rest of us because he needs so much time to play these "quarterback" passes people rave about, that it makes him so easy to put under pressure which inevitibly leads to him losing possession. Lets use the munich game as an example...he was brushed off like an old woman for the first goal and his sloppy pass led to the corner for the second. The liverpool game he was also the guilty party when he gave away cheap possession which led to Torres opener. The article says he suffered due to having to play centre back and it allowed fletcher to build his rep. Forgive me if im wrong, but was fletcher not beside him in defence, either at right back or centre half? A terrible article all round really

dustybinney (Manchester United): Carrick is great when United are on top and goes missing when United aren`t. He cannot handle being harressed by players. That being said, you can see what happened to liverpool when you take his style of player out of their team in alonso. So maybe he is one of those you don`t miss until they aren`t there.....but a def midfielder (hargreave, mascherano etc) he is not and we have asked him to be one. The fact we have been playing 5 in midfield this season tells you we have no faith in our midfield players to dominate games...too many functional players and not enough specialist/dominante players there.

lisbabylover (Manchester United): This is undeniably the worst most blinkered teamtalk column i've ever read! It was so bad that I felt compled to register to comment to point that out! Carrick has one attribute...his passing but put him under the slightest bit of pressure and he'll play a lousy pass or get caught in possession. It's easy to look good in a team when you've Rooney Ronaldo etc ahead of you but irrespective of who's on the same team as him or who united are against, put any bit of pressure on Carrick and he'll be found out for what he is - the most overrated player in the epl!
Oncy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-04-2010, 11:14 AM   #2
rondwisan
moderator
udah sebelas yaa :)
 
 
rondwisan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Soe Rock Bo Yo - Nga Lam vv
Posts: 35,048
Thanks: 1,500
Thanked 4,736 Times in 2,701 Posts
Mentioned: 567 Post(s)
rondwisan has a reputation beyond reputerondwisan has a reputation beyond reputerondwisan has a reputation beyond reputerondwisan has a reputation beyond reputerondwisan has a reputation beyond reputerondwisan has a reputation beyond reputerondwisan has a reputation beyond reputerondwisan has a reputation beyond reputerondwisan has a reputation beyond reputerondwisan has a reputation beyond reputerondwisan has a reputation beyond repute
Visit rondwisan's Facebook Visit rondwisan's Twitter
Default Re: Carrick overrated?

hmmm ..., nunggu comment Bang Ucup dulu deh ....
__________________
“Let’s not underestimate the other teams. They are very good teams and there are a lot of games to play before the end of the season. We’re in a good position. But that means nothing if you don’t win the next game.” - Dimitar Berbatov
rondwisan is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-04-2010, 11:15 AM   #3
dhona.7
academy
-
 
 
dhona.7's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Jakarta
Posts: 393
Thanks: 15
Thanked 81 Times in 20 Posts
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
dhona.7 Ready for being a real United Indonesia
Post Re: Carrick overrated?

hmmm, liat comment teman" yg lain dlu deh...
dhona.7 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-04-2010, 11:24 AM   #4
Anderstone
reserve player
-
 
 
Anderstone's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Bishop Blaize
Posts: 529
Thanks: 8
Thanked 241 Times in 75 Posts
Mentioned: 3 Post(s)
Anderstone will become famous soon enough


Default Re: Carrick overrated?

Dia gak over-rated, musim pertama dan keduanya di United itu dia berperan penting banget kalo gue bilang bikin lini tengah jadi seimbang pada masa-masa sebelum Fletcher berubah jadi monster kaya sekarang.

Tapi musim ini adalah musim terburuk dia, kita juga tahu kok musim ini dia bermain di bawah form, jauh banget kalo dibandingin sama dua musim pertamanya.
__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 0 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

LUHG
Anderstone is offline   Reply With Quote
The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Anderstone For This Useful Post:
Old 15-04-2010, 11:30 AM   #5
goodfron
first team
Eagle Flies Alone
 
 
goodfron's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Soerabaia
Posts: 3,596
Thanks: 420
Thanked 1,046 Times in 430 Posts
Mentioned: 24 Post(s)
goodfron is just really nicegoodfron is just really nicegoodfron is just really nicegoodfron is just really nicegoodfron is just really nice


Visit goodfron's Facebook Visit goodfron's Twitter
Default Re: Carrick overrated?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Anderstone View Post
Dia gak over-rated, musim pertama dan keduanya di United itu dia berperan penting banget kalo gue bilang bikin lini tengah jadi seimbang pada masa-masa sebelum Fletcher berubah jadi monster kaya sekarang.

Tapi musim ini adalah musim terburuk dia, kita juga tahu kok musim ini dia bermain di bawah form, jauh banget kalo dibandingin sama dua musim pertamanya.
betul.. kalo' Carrick gak bisa dibilang overatted ato flop... soalnya dua musim sebelumnya masih memberikan kontribusi yg signifikan.. musim ini dia turun banget performanya.. apa gara2 abis "diperkosa" Xavi pas final Champion di Roma ya? masih trauma gitu?
goodfron is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-04-2010, 11:49 AM   #6
dancoloveunited
first team
United till I die
 
 
dancoloveunited's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: |D|E|P|O|K|
Posts: 1,257
Thanks: 604
Thanked 345 Times in 118 Posts
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
dancoloveunited is a jewel in the roughdancoloveunited is a jewel in the roughdancoloveunited is a jewel in the rough
Default Re: Carrick overrated?

for me, he's not overrated...

dia bagus kok di 2 musim pertamanya, musim kemarin emang agak menurun dan musim ini nggak lebih baik dari musim kemarin... gw gak tau kenapa... keliatan ada tekanan dan banyak pikiran gitu kalo dia main sekarang...

well, sedikit OOT, kayaknya nasibnya kebalik sama si #9 nih...

Carrick = dua musim pertama bagus, selanjutnya menurun...

#9 = dua musim pertama flop, selanjutnya??? apakah akan bagus???

I don't think so...

semoga Carrick tetap bertahan dan kembali ke performa dia yang sebenarnya seperti di 06/07 & 07/08...

dancoloveunited is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-04-2010, 12:07 PM   #7
B4YU
first team
-
 
 
B4YU's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 1,280
Thanks: 58
Thanked 196 Times in 124 Posts
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
B4YU has a spectacular aura aboutB4YU has a spectacular aura about
Default Re: Carrick overrated?

Carrick overrated?? jelas tidak setuju...

Carrick Flop??? ...setuju ... kalau ukurannya musim ini dan dibandingkan dengan musim sebelumnya tentunya... dia menurut gw gagal di musim ini..

sepanjang musim ini permainan dia jauh menurun ketimbang musim sebelumnya..

sebabnya??? ... entahlah gw sendiri jg belum tahu sebab pastinya.. dan berharap dia segera bisa mengangkat kembali permainannya ..

karena posisi nya sangat rawan "tergusur" menurut gw jika keseringan tampil di bawah performa terbaiknya...

OOT... Vidic juga hampir sama kasusnya.. tapi mgkn faktor cedera di awal musim utk Vidic jg berpengaruh...
__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 0 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
B4YU is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-04-2010, 12:18 PM   #8
red_devilz
first team
You're mine :)
 
 
red_devilz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: kaki langit
Posts: 1,019
Thanks: 439
Thanked 270 Times in 110 Posts
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
red_devilz is a jewel in the roughred_devilz is a jewel in the roughred_devilz is a jewel in the rough
Default Re: Carrick overrated?

TBH, pemain United yg tampil dalam performa terbaiknya pada musim ini hanya ada 3 orang .... Rooney , Fletcher , dan Evra

Sementara performa pemain2 lainnya cenderung "up and down" , including Carrick ...

Posisi Carrick mirip dengan Pirlo d A.C Milan ..... deep lying playmaker

IMHO, Carrick masih memiliki masa depan yg cerah d United .... dia bisa ditempatkan sebagai Bek Tengah dadakan juga sebagai alternatif dan solusi ketika United mengalami krisis pemain belakang ...

Seorang Ryan Giggs pun pernah mengalami penurunan performa (pada musim 01/02 ) ... so, give him (Carrick) a longer time to prove his class ...

*FYI, Carrick adalah tipikal pemain yg disukai Fergie (dr segi sifat ) , seorang pemain yg datang ke Carrington tepat waktu (di pagi / sore hari ) dan lebih memilih menghabiskan waktu senggang bersama keluarga ...
red_devilz is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-04-2010, 12:47 PM   #9
seven7
first team
bapakekamal
 
 
seven7's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 1,238
Thanks: 150
Thanked 302 Times in 115 Posts
Mentioned: 83 Post(s)
seven7 is a name known to allseven7 is a name known to allseven7 is a name known to allseven7 is a name known to allseven7 is a name known to allseven7 is a name known to allseven7 is a name known to all
Default Re: Carrick overrated?

sudah 4 tahun carrick bermain di MU...dan musim ini adalah penampilan terburuknya. Jadi gw kurang setuju kalo kita langsung menilai Carrick Overrated.
memang sih pembelian dia dari Spurs bisa di bilang "agak mahal" tapi.. 2 musim pertamanya menunjukan performa yang sangat baik dan orang menjadi "sedikit" melupakan "harga pembelian" dia...tapi bukan dengan performa buruk ditahun ini lantas cap "overated" bisa langsung menempel didirinya...
seven7 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-04-2010, 04:36 PM   #10
yoshiharu_kubo10
first team
Get up, stand up...Stand up
for your rights...Get up,
stand up...Don't give up the
fight...
 
 
yoshiharu_kubo10's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: not here...
Posts: 2,063
Thanks: 2,004
Thanked 487 Times in 291 Posts
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
yoshiharu_kubo10 is a glorious beacon of lightyoshiharu_kubo10 is a glorious beacon of lightyoshiharu_kubo10 is a glorious beacon of lightyoshiharu_kubo10 is a glorious beacon of lightyoshiharu_kubo10 is a glorious beacon of lightyoshiharu_kubo10 is a glorious beacon of light
Default Re: Carrick overrated?

yups...

aku rasa penyebutan overrated untuk Michael Carrick itu tidak tepat...

dia memang mempunyai kemampuan passing yang baik...dia cukup baik juga mengatur tempo permainan...

hanya saja...musim ini memang penampilannya tidak baik...dia bahkan tenggelam oleh Fletcher...
yoshiharu_kubo10 is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


(View-All Members who have read this thread : 32
Aba_MaczUnited, bang_zak, Blacklist7, Bloody "Devil" R3d, Cendhul, dekepiks, dellamendoza, ebol, ecly_watchaa, eyeofday, fadlysyah, Fajar_, ferly_Liemz, fredrian.seven, GeaErang, goodmin, Gustiono, jifortin, penk22_, Redsbusby, rio vander vidic, ronald hars, Ryan Firmanda, Trezz Kiko, tumpal_oneunited, UNITED1878, Van_Munandar, Victory, word89vkodv, Zee de Wazza, zudomiriku
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
City Started Mind Game :P theater of dream United Lounge 53 21-11-2012 11:19 PM
started winger pilihan Loe ... rondwisan United Lounge 34 25-11-2010 09:47 PM
Lack of Leadership theater of dream United Lounge 36 22-04-2010 12:13 PM
UICS - Charity Program (up date: Banjir Kerawang, started page #10) sir_otz Surabaya 95 29-03-2010 03:51 PM
[G] Lack Of Everything @ Goodison Park Stadium (Everton 3-1 Manchester United) drivemein Archives 2009/2010 8 23-02-2010 10:10 AM



All times are GMT +8. The time now is 06:29 PM.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
United Indonesia - Manchester United Supporters Club of Indonesia