The Dubious Goals Panel [Updated]

[Redsbusby]

Berba dinyatakan mencetak 20 GOL, bukan 21 GOL!!!
Gol ke gawang SUnderland tgl 26 Desember dinyatakan sebagai Own Goal oleh DGP. Dengan demikian Tevez yang mengoleksi 19 gol hanya selisih 1 gol saja dengan Berba

Dubious goals panel ruling
The Premier League's Dubious Goals Panel has viewed all dubious goals for 30th November 2010 to 19th April 2011.


The Dubious Goals Committee has ruled on the following:

1) Stoke City's first goal against Wigan Athletic on 4th December 2010 has been confirmed as a Robert Huth goal.

2) Wigan Athletic's first goal against Stoke City on 4th December 2010 has been confirmed as an own goal (Daniel Collins).

3) Wigan Athletic's second goal against Stoke City on 4th December 2010 was in fact an own goal (Rory Delap) and has therefore not been credited to Tom Cleverley.

4) West Bromwich Albion's third goal against Newcastle United on 5th December 2010 has been confirmed as a Peter Odemwingie goal.

5) West Bromwich Albion's goal against Aston Villa on 11th December 2010 has been confirmed as a Paul Scharner goal.

6) Liverpool's goal against Newcastle United on 11th December 2010 has been confirmed as a Dirk Kuyt goal.

7) Manchester City's second goal against West Ham United on 11th December 2010 has been confirmed as a Yaya Toure goal.

8) West Ham United's goal against Manchester City on 11th December 2010 has been confirmed as a James Tomkins goal.

9) Blackburn Rovers' goal against Bolton Wanderers on 12th December 2010 has been confirmed as a Mame Biram Diouf goal.

10) Manchester City's goal against Everton on 20th December 2010 has been confirmed as a Yaya Toure goal.

11) Manchester United's second goal against Sunderland on 26th December 2010 was in fact an own goal (Anton Ferdinand) and has therefore not been credited to Dimitar Berbatov.

12) Manchester City's third goal against Newcastle United on 26th December 2010 was in fact an own goal (Fabricio Colocinni) and has therefore not been credited to Carlos Tevez.


Drogba goal

13) Tottenham Hotspur's first goal against Newcastle United on 28th December 2010 has been confirmed as an Aaron Lennon goal.

14) West Ham United's goal against Everton on 28th December 2010 has been confirmed as an own goal (Tony Hibbert).

15) Arsenal's first goal against Birmingham City on 1st January 2011 has been confirmed as a Robin Van Persie goal.

16) Manchester City's goal against Blackpool on 1st January 2011 has been confirmed as an Adam Johnson goal.

17) Sunderland's first goal against Blackburn Rovers on 1st January 2011 has been confirmed as a Daniel Welbeck goal.

18) Chelsea's second goal against Aston Villa on 2nd January 2011 has been confirmed as a Didier Drogba goal.

19) Wolverhampton Wanderers' goal against Chelsea on 5th January 2011 has been confirmed as an own goal (Jose Bosingwa)

20) Manchester City's first goal against Wolverhampton Wanderers on 15th January 2011 has been confirmed as a Kolo Toure goal.

21) Stoke City's first goal against Bolton Wanderers on 15th January 2011 has been confirmed as a Daniel Higginbotham goal.

22) West Bromwich Albion's second goal against Blackpool on 15th January 2011 has been confirmed as a James Morrison goal.

23) Aston Villa's goal against Birmingham City on 16th January 2011 has been confirmed as a James Collins goal.

24) Chelsea's third goal against Bolton Wanderers on 24th January 2011 has been confirmed as a Nicolas Anelka goal.


Suarez goal

25) Wigan Athletic's goal against Aston Villa on 25th January 2011 has been confirmed as a James McCarthy goal.

26) Manchester City's first goal against Birmingham City on 2nd February 2011 has been confirmed as a Carlos Tevez goal.

27) Liverpool's second goal against Stoke City on 2nd February 2011 has been confirmed as a Luis Suarez goal.

28) Bolton Wanderers' first goal against Everton on 13th February 2011 has been confirmed as a Gary Cahill goal.

29) Tottenham Hotspur's goal against Blackpool on 22nd February 2011 was in fact an own goal (Craig Cathcart) and has therefore not been credited to Roman Pavlyuchenko.

30) Bolton Wanderers' second goal against Aston Villa on 5th March 2011 has been confirmed as a Gary Cahill goal.

31) Blackburn Rovers' first goal against Fulham on 5th March 2011 was in fact an own goal (Brede Hangeland) and has therefore not been credited to Grant Hanley.

32) Blackburn Rovers' second goal against Blackpool on 19th March 2011 has been confirmed as a David Hoilett goal.

33) Fulham's second goal against Blackpool on 3rd April 2011 has been confirmed as a Bobby Zamora goal.

34) West Bromwich Albion's first goal against Sunderland on 9th April 2011 has been confirmed as a Peter Odemwingie goal.

35) West Bromwich Albion's second goal against Sunderland on 9th April 2011 has been confirmed as a Youssouf Mulumbu goal.

36) Wigan Athletic's third goal against Blackpool on 16th April 2011 has been confirmed as an own goal (Neal Eardley).

37) Everton's first goal against Blackburn Rovers on 16th April 2011 has been confirmed as a Leon Osman goal.

http://www.premierleague.com/page/Headlines/0,,12306~2361167,00.html

[Redsbusby]

^^

12) Manchester City's third goal against Newcastle United on 26th December 2010 was in fact an own goal (Fabricio Colocinni) and has therefore not been credited to Carlos Tevez.

Dan kemudian kembali ke selisih 2 gol antara Berba- tevez karena gol ketiga city oleh tevez saat melawan Newcastle dianulir menjadi Own Goal...

[fadilbedil]

tapi tetep percaya berba jadi topskor musim ini
semoga lawan blackpool berba bisa cetak skor lagi

[rondwisan]

semalem Tevez bikin 2 gol lagi ...
jadi sama nih golnya Berba ama Tevez ..

btw, di web premierleague.co.uk untuk statistik topscorenya masih blom berubah tuh ... ???

[theater of dream]

kalo gol berba dikurangi maka tevez yg diatas

[rondwisan]

Dubious Goals: 13th Aug to 11th Oct

The Dubious Goals Panel has viewed all dubious goals for the period 13th August 2011 to 11th October 2011.

*

The Dubious Goals Committee has ruled on the following:

1) Bolton Wanderers' second goal against Queens Park Rangers on 13th August 2011 has been confirmed as an own goal (Danny Gabbidon).

2) Bolton Wanderers' third goal against Queens Park Rangers on 13th August 2011 has been confirmed as an Ivan Klasnic goal.

3) Manchester United's second goal against West Bromwich Albion on 14th August 2011 has been confirmed as an own goal (Steven Reid).

4) Queens Park Rangers' goal against Everton on 20th August 2011 has been confirmed as a Tommy Smith goal.

5) Chelsea's first goal against West Bromwich Albion on 20th August 2011 has been confirmed as a Nicolas Anelka goal.

6) Wigan Athletic's first goal against Queens Park Rangers on 27th August 2011 has been confirmed as a Franco Di Santo goal.

7) Wigan Athletic's second goal against Queens Park Rangers on 27th August 2011 has been confirmed as a Franco Di Santo goal.

8) Chelsea's first goal against Sunderland on 10th September 2011 has been confirmed as a John Terry goal.

9) Chelsea's second goal against Sunderland on 10th September 2011 has been confirmed as a Daniel Sturridge goal.

10) Norwich City's first goal against Bolton Wanderers on 17th September 2011 has been confirmed as an Anthony Pilkington goal.

11) Wigan Athletic's goal against Everton on 17th September 2011 has been confirmed as a Franco Di Santo goal.

12) Fulham's second goal against Manchester City on 18th September 2011 was in fact an own goal (Vincent Kompany) and has therefore not been credited to Danny Murphy.

13) Sunderland's third goal against Stoke City on 18th September 2011 has been confirmed as a Craig Gardner goal.

14) Manchester City's first goal against Everton on 24th September 2011 has been confirmed as a Mario Balotelli goal.

15) Liverpool's first goal against Wolverhampton Wanderers on 24th September 2011 has been confirmed as an own goal (Roger Johnson).

16) Manchester City's third goal against Blackburn Rovers on 1st October 2011 has been confirmed as a Samir Nasri goal.

17) West Bromwich Albion's first goal against Sunderland on 1st October 2011 has been confirmed as a James Morrison goal.

18) Sunderland's first goal against West Bromwich Albion on 1st October 2011 has been confirmed as a Nicklas Bendtner goal.